The Library

Beyond East-West : marginality and national dignity in Finnish identity construction

Tools

Browning, Christopher S. and Lehti, Marko. (2007) Beyond East-West : marginality and national dignity in Finnish identity construction. Nationalities Papers, Vol.35 (No.4). pp. 691-716. ISSN 0090-5992

Preview

PDF
WRAP_Browning_0674383-060709-finnish_marginality_narratives_final.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
Download (181Kb)

Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00905990701475103

Abstract

Since the end of the Cold War it has become common for Finnish academics and politicians alike to frame debates about Finnish national identity in terms of locating Finland somewhere along a continuum between East and West (e.g., Harle and Moisio 2000). Indeed, for politicians properly locating oneself (and therefore Finland) along this continuum has often been seen as central to the winning and losing of elections. For example, the 1994 referendum on EU membership was largely interpreted precisely as an opportunity to relocate Finland further to the West (Jakobson 1998, 111; Arter 1995). Indeed, the tendency to depict Finnish history in terms of a series of ‘westernising’ moves has been notable, but has also betrayed some of the politicised elements of this view (Browning 2002). However, this framing of Finnish national identity discourse is not only sometimes politicised, but arguably is also too simplified and results in blindness towards other identity narratives that have also been important through Finnish history, and that are also evident (but rarely recognised) today as well. In this article we aim to highlight one of these that we argue has played a key role in locating Finland in the world and in formulating notions of what Finland is about, what historical role and mission it has been understood as destined to play, and what futures for the nation have been conceptualised as possible and as providing a source of subjectivity and national dignity. The focus of this article is therefore on the relationship between Finnish nationalism and ideas of ‘marginality’ through Finnish history.

Item Type:

Journal Article

Subjects:

D History General and Old World > DL Northern Europe. Scandinavia
H Social Sciences > HM Sociology

Divisions:

Faculty of Social Sciences > Politics and International Studies

Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):

National characteristics -- Finland, Cold War, Marginality, Social, Finland -- Social conditions, Finland -- Politics and government

Journal or Publication Title:

Nationalities Papers

Publisher:

Routledge

ISSN:

0090-5992

Official Date:

September 2007

Dates:

Date	Event
September 2007	Published

Volume:

Vol.35

Number:

No.4

Page Range:

pp. 691-716

Identification Number:

10.1080/00905990701475103

Status:

Peer Reviewed

Access rights to Published version:

Open Access

References:

* 1. Aho, J. (1995) Pioneers. Scandinavian Short Stories pp. 275-278. Senate , London
* 2. Alasuutari, P. and Ruuska, P. (1999) Post-Patria? Globalisaation kulttuuri Suomessa Vastapaino , Tampere
* 3. Antola, E. (2004) Suomi EU:n etujoukkoon—Eurooppa-politiikan uudet haasteet EVA , Helsinki
* 4. Anttonen, P. J. (2005) Tradition through Modernity: Postmodernism and the Nation-State in Folklore Scholarship Finnish Literature Society , Helsinki
* 5. Ardener, E. Jackson, A. (ed) (1987) Remote Areas: Some Theoretical Considerations. Anthropology at Home pp. 38-54. Tavistock , London
* 6. Arter, D. (1995) The EU Referendum in Finland on 16 October 1994: A Vote for the West, not for Maastricht. Journal of Common Market Studies 33:3 , pp. 361-387.
* 7. Arter, D. (1998) Kekkonen and the 'Dark Age' of Finlandised Politics?. Irish Studies in International Affairs 9 , pp. 39-49.
* 8. Breuilly, J. (1985) Nationalism and the State University of Chicago Press , Chicago
* 9. Browning, C. S. (2002) Coming Home or Moving Home? 'Westernising' Narratives in Finnish Foreign Policy and the Re-interpretation of Past Identities. Cooperation and Conflict 37:1 , pp. 47-72.
* 10. Browning, C. S. Lars, Hedegaard and Bjarne, Lindstroumlm (eds) (2003) Towards a New Agenda? US, Russian and EU Policies in Northern Europe. The NEBI Yearbook 2003—North European and Baltic Sea Integration pp. 273-289. Springer , Berlin
* 11. Browning, C. S. and Joenniemi, P. (2004) Contending Discourses of Marginality: The Case of Kaliningrad. Geopolitics 9:3 , pp. 699-730.
* 12. Butler, J. (1997) Excitable Speech: A Politics of the Performative Routledge , New York
* 13. Castells, M. and Himanen, P. (2004) The Information Society and the Welfare State: The Finnish Model Oxford University Press , Oxford
* 14. Cohen, Saul Bernard (1964) Geography and World Politics in a Divided World Methuen , London
* 15. Connery, D. S. (1966) The Scandinavians Simon & Schuster , New York
* 16. Eglitis, D. S. (2004) Imagining the Nation: History, Modernity and Revolution in Latvia Pennsylvania State University Press , University Park
* 17. Engman, M. (2002) Lejonet och duppeloumlrnen. Finlands imperiella decennier 1830-1890 Atlantis , Stockholm
* 18. Greenfeld, L. (1995) Nationalism: Five Roads to Modernity Harvard University Press , Cambridge, MA
* 19. Griffiths, T. (1993) Scandinavia Wakefield Press , Kent Town
* 20. Hadjuacute, Z. and Paasi, A. (1995) The Changing Representations of Finland in Geographical Texts in Hungary: A Contextual Analysis. Fennia 173:1 , pp. 33-51.
* 21. Hall, W. (1953) Green Gold and Granite: A Background to Finland Max Parrish , London
* 22. Hanhimaumlki, J. M. (1997) Scandinavia and the United States Twayne , New York
* 23. Hannula, J. O. (1939) Finland's War of Independence Faber and Faber , London
* 24. Harle, V. and Moisio, S. (2000) Missauml on Suomi? Kansallisen identiteettipolitiikan historia ja geopolitiikka Vastapaino , Jyvaumlskylauml — (Where is Finland? The nation's history of identity politics and geopolitics)
* 25. Hechter, M. (2000) Containing Nationalism Oxford University Press , Oxford
* 26. Hroch, M. (1985) Social Preconditions of National Revival in Europe: A Comparative Analysis of the Social Composition of Patriotic Groups among the Smaller European Nations Cambridge University Press , Cambridge
* 27. Huxley, S. D. (1990) Constitutionalist Insurgency in Finland: Finnish “Passive Resistance” against Russification as a Case of Nonmilitary Struggle in the European Resistance Tradition Suomen historiallinen seura , Helsinki
* 28. Immonen, K. (1987) Ryssaumlstauml saa puhua …: Neuvostoliitto suomalaisessa julkisuudessa ja kirjat julkisuuden muotona 1918-39 Otava , Helsinki
* 29. Jakobson, M. (1998) Finland in the New Europe Praeger , Westport, CT
* 30. Joenniemi, P. Hansen, L. and Waever, O. (eds) (2002) Finland in the New Europe: A Herderian or Hegelian Project. European Integration and National Identity: The Challenge of the Nordic States pp. 182-213. Routledge , London and New York
* 31. Joenniemi, P. Moumlller, F. and Pehkonen, S. (eds) (2003) Can Europe Be Told from the North? Tapping into the EU's Northern Dimension. Encountering the North: Cultural Geography, International Relations and Northern Landscapes pp. 221-260. Ashgate , Aldershot
* 32. Jokisipilauml, M. (2005) Suomalainen historiallinen myytti. Tieteessauml tapahtuu 2 , pp. 16-22.
* 33. Karemaa, O. (1998) Vihollisia, vainoojia, syoumlpaumllaumlisiauml. Venaumllaumlisviha Suomessa 1917-1923 Suomen historiallinen seura , Helsinki
* 34. Kekkonen, U. (1970) Neutrality: The Finnish Position Heinemann , London
* 35. Kemilaumlinen, A. (1998) Finns in the Shadow of the “Aryans”: Race Theories and Racism SHS , Helsinki — Studia Historica 59
* 36. Kettunen, P. (2001) The Nordic Welfare State in Finland. Scandinavian Journal of History 26:3 , pp. 227-247. [informaworld]
* 37. Kivi, A. (1991) Seven Brothers Finnish American Translators Association , New Paltz
* 38. Klinge, M. (1993) The Finnish Tradition: Essays on Structures and Identities in the North of Europe SHS , Helsinki
* 39. Klinge, M. (1997) Keisarin Suomi Schildts , Espoo
* 40. Korhonen, K. Heiskanen, I., Huopaniemi, J., Korhonen, K. and Toumlrnudd, K. (eds) (1969) Finland and the Soviet Union. Essays on Finnish Foreign Policy pp. 31-40. Finnish Political Science Association , Vammala
* 41. Koskinen, Y. S. (1869) Oppikirja Suomen kansan historiasta Suomalaisen Kirjallisuuden Seura , Helsinki
* 42. Kuisma, M. (2003) Consistent Continuity and Contingent Change: Globalisation, European Integration and the Paths of Citizenship in Finland and Norway University of Birmingham — Unpublished Ph.D. diss
* 43. Laine, K. (1999) “Paumlaumlosassa Suomen kansa”: Suomi-Filmin ja Suomen Filmiteollisuus kansallisen elokuvan rakentajina 1933-1939 SKS , Helsinki
* 44. Lehti, M. (1999) A Baltic League as a Construct of the New Europe: Envisioning a Baltic Region and Small State Sovereignty in the Aftermath of the First World War Peter Lang , Frankfurt-am-Main
* 45. Lehti, M. (2000) Kansojen kilvoittelu kunniasta. Kansallisuusaatteen ja urheilun pyhauml liitto. Historiallinen Aikakauskirja 3 , pp. 226-240.
* 46. Lehti, M. Joenniemi, P. (ed) (2001) The Petersburgian Europe in Finnish Identity. Saint Petersburg—Russian, European and Beyond pp. 3-20. Saint-Petersburg University Press , St. Petersburg
* 47. Lehti, M. Heinonen, M. (ed) (2002) Pohjoisen paluu. Uudet tarinat ja vanhat symbolit. Dialogus. Historian taito pp. 347-366. Kirja-Aurora , Turku
* 48. Lehtonen, T. M. (1999) Europe's Northern Frontier: Perspectives on Finland's Western Identity PS Kustannus , Jyvaumlskylauml
* 49. Liulevicius, V. (2000) War Land on the Eastern Front: Culture, National Identity, and German Occupation in World War I Cambridge University Press , Cambridge
* 50. Meinander, H. (1999) Tasavallan tiellauml. Suomi kansalaissodasta 2000-luvulle Schildts , Espoo
* 51. Mikkeli, H. (1992) Metsaumlturkki ja sen jurot parturit. Naumlkemyksiauml metsaumlluonnon ja kansaluonteen suhteesta 1800- ja 1900-luvuilla. Historiallinen Aikakauskirja 92:3 , pp. 200-214.
* 52. Moisio, S. and Harle, V. (2002) Karhu poliittis-maantieteellisenauml naapurina: kansallinen identiteettiprojekti 2000-luvun Suomessa Turku University , Turku
* 53. A Northern Dimension for the Policies of the European Union Virtual Finland — Video directed by P. Stenlund and M. Nissinen, < virtual.finland.fi/finfo/english/northdim2.html > (accessed February 2007)
* 54. Nousiainen, J. (1963) The Parties and Foreign Policy. Finnish Foreign Policy pp. 117-195. Finnish Political Science Association , Helsinki
* 55. Paasi, A. (1996) Territories, Boundaries and Consciousness: The Changing Geographies of the Finnish-Russian Border John Wiley , Chichester
* 56. Paasikivi, J. K. (1956) Paasikiven Linja I: Juho Kusti Paasikiven Puheita Vuosilta 1944-1956 WSOY , Porvoo
* 57. Paasivirta, J. (1963) Finland och de olympiska spelen i Stockholm: diplomatin bakon kulisserna Ekenaumls Tryckeri , Ekenaumls
* 58. Peuranen, E. Lapola, M. (ed) (1995) Pietarin todellisuudet ja myytit. Suomi & Pierari WSOY , Helsinki
* 59. Pihlaja, J. (1999) The Wild East Begins Just across the Border. Helsingin Sanomat International Edition 23 — <(accessed" target="new">http://www.helsinki-hs.net/thisweek/43041999.html> (accessed 26 October 1999)
* 60. Repo, E. and Melander, T. Finnish Information Technology in Good Form. — April 2005, < " target="new">http://virtual.finland.fi> (accessed 9 April 2005)
* 61. Ringmar, E. (1996) Identity, Interest and Action: A Cultural Explanation of Sweden's Intervention in the Thirty Years War Cambridge University Press , Cambridge
* 62. Roshwald, A. (2001) Ethnic Nationalism & the Fall of Empires: Central Europe, Russia & the Middle East, 1914-1923 Routledge , London and New York
* 63. Ruokanen, T. (2004) Suomen menestyksen evaumlaumlt: Tiekartta tulevaisuuteen EVA , Helsinki
* 64. Ruokanen, T. and Nurmio, A. (1995) Entauml jos … Suomi ja mahdolliset maailmat WSOY , Porvoo
* 65. Salmi, H. and Kallioniemi, K. Salmi, H. and Kallioniemi, K. (eds) (2000) Pohjan taumlhteiden tuolla puolen. Pohjan taumlhteet. Populaarikulttuurin kuva suomalaisuudesta pp. 7-21. Kirjastopalvelut , Helsinki
* 66. Salokangas, R. Endeacuten, R. (ed) (1996) The Finnish Broadcasting Company and the Changing Finnish Society, 1949-1966. Yleisradio 1926-1996: A History of Broadcasting in Finland pp. 107-228. WSOY Painolaistokset , Helsinki
* 67. Shields, R. (1991) Places on the Margin: Alternative Geographies of Modernity Routledge , London
* 68. Smeds, K. (1996) Helsingfors-Paris: Finlands utveckling till nation paring vaumlrldsutstaumlllningarna 1851-1900 Svenska litteratursaumlllskapet i Finland: Finska historiska samfundet , Helsingfors
* 69. Smith, A. D. (2003) Chosen Peoples: Sacred Sources of National Identity Cambridge University Press , Cambridge
* 70. Tiilikainen, T. (2006) Finland—an EU Member with a Small State Identity. European Integration 28:1 , pp. 73-87.
* 71. Valenius, J. (2004) Undressing the Maid: Gender, Sexuality and the Body in the Construction of the Finnish Nation SKS , Helsinki
* 72. Viljanen, V. M. J. (1920) Suomi, reunavallat ja Venaumljaumln kysymys: talouspoliittinen tutkielma Edistysseurojen kustannus , Helsinki
* 73. Waeligver, O. (1992) Nordic Nostalgia: Northern Europe after the Cold War. International Affairs 68:1 , pp. 77-102.
* 74. Waeligver, O. Hansen, L. and Waeligver, O. (eds) (2002) Identities, Communities and Foreign Policy: Discourse Analysis as Foreign Policy Theory. Between Nations and Europe: Regionalism, Nationalism and the Politics of Union pp. 20-49. Routledge , London
* 75. Wiik, K. (2002) Eurooppalaisten juuret pp. 20-49. Ateena , Jyvaumlskylauml
* 76. Wilson, W. A. (1976) Folklore and Nationalism in Modern Finland Indiana University Press , Bloomington