Markevich, Andreĭ, 1976- (2007) The dictator’s dilemma: to punish or to assist? Plan failures and interventions under Stalin. Working Paper. Coventry: University of Warwick, Department of Economics. (Warwick economic research papers.

Preview

PDF WRAP_Markevich_twerp_816.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader Download (234Kb)

Abstract

A dictator issues an order, but the order is not carried out. The dictator does not know whether the order failed because the agent behaved opportunistically, or because his order contained some mistake. Imperfect information creates his dilemma : whether to punish the agent, or assist her or both. This paper models the dictator’s intervention when an order fails. The analysis links the dictator’s coercive policy with the softness of budget constraints. The model is verified against the history of Stalin’s dictatorship, using statistical evidence extracted from the formerly secret records of the Communist Party's "control commission".

Item Type:	Working or Discussion Paper (Working Paper)
Subjects:	H Social Sciences > HC Economic History and Conditions D History General and Old World > DK Russia. Soviet Union. Former Soviet Republics
Divisions:	Faculty of Social Sciences > Economics
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):	Stalin, Joseph, 1879-1953, Dictatorship -- Soviet Union, Information asymmetry, Decision making, Soviet Union -- Politics and government -- 1936-1953, Soviet Union -- Economic conditions -- 1917-1945, Soviet Union -- Economic conditions -- 1945-1955
Series Name:	Warwick economic research papers
Publisher:	University of Warwick, Department of Economics
Place of Publication:	Coventry
Date:	2007
Number:	No.816
Number of Pages:	44
Status:	Not Peer Reviewed
Access rights to Published version:	Open Access
References:	Belova, Eugenia, 2001. Economic Crime and Punishment. In: Gregory, Paul (Ed.) Behind the Façade of Stalin’s Command Economy: Evidence from the State and Party Archives, Hoover Institution Press, Stanford, CA, pp. 131-58. Belova, Eugenia and Paul Gregory, 2002. Dictators, loyal and opportunistic agents: The Soviet archives on creating the Soviet economic system. Public Choice, 113(3-4), 265-286. Berliner, Joseph S, 1957. Factory and Manager in the USSR. Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, Mass. Davies R.W., 2006. The Soviet Economy and the Launching of the Great Terror. In: Ilic, Melanie (Ed.) Stalin's Terror Revisited, Palgrave, Houndmills, UK. Denisov V.V., Kvashonkin A.V., Malashenko L.N., Minuk A.I. Prosumenshchikov M.Yu., Khlevnyuk O.V. (Compilers), 2004. TsK VKP9b) i regional’nie partiinie komiteti 1945 – 1953, Rosspen, Moskva. Friedman, J., 1971. A Non-cooperative Equilibrium for Supergames. Review of Economic Studies, 38, 1-12. Getty, Arch, 1997. Pragmatists and Puritans: The Rise and Fall of the Party Control Commission. The Carl Beck Papers in Russian and East European Studies. No. 1208. Gorlizki, Yoram, 1999. Rules, Incentives and Soviet Campaign Justice After World War II. Europe-Asia Studies, 51(7), 1245-1265. Gorlizki, Yoram, 2001. Theft Under Stalin: A Property Rights Analysis. PERSA Working PaperNo. 10. Granick, David, 1954. Management of the Industrial Firm in the USSR. Columbia Univ. Press, New York. Gregory, Paul R., 1990. Restructuring the Soviet economic bureaucracy. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Gregory, Paul R., 2004. The Political Economy of Stalinism: Evidence from the Soviet Secret Archives. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Gregory Paul and Mark Harrison, 2005. Allocation under Dictatorship: Research in Stalin’s Archives, Journal of Economic Literature, XLIII, 721-761. Gregory, Paul and Andrei Markevich, 2002. Creating Soviet Industry: the House That Stalin Built, Slavic Review, 61(4), 787-814. Gregory, Paul, Philipp Schroder and Konstantin Sonin, 2006. Dictators, Repression and the Median Citizen: An Eliminations Model of Stalin’s Terror (Data from the NKVD Archives),Working paper No. 91 CEFIR/NES Working paper series. Harris, James, 2003. Was Stalin a Weak Dictator? The Journal of Modern History, 75, 375-386. Harrison, Mark, 2005. The Fundamental Problem of Command: Plan and Compliance in a Partially Centralized Economy. Comparative Economic Studies 47(2), 296-314. Hayek, F.A., 1944. The Road to Selfdom. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago. Ikonnikov, S. N., 1971. Sozdanie i deiatel’nost’ ob’edinennykh organov TsKK - RKI v 1923-1934 gg. Nauka, Moskva. Holland Hunter and Janusz M. Szyrmer, 1992. Faulty foundations: Soviet economic policies, 1928-1940. Princeton University Press, Princeton/Oxford,. Khlevnuk O.V., Gorlizkii J., Kosheleva L.P., Minuk A.I., Prozumenshchikova M.Yu., Rogovaya L.A., Somonova S.V. (compilers), 2002. Politburo TsK VKP(b) I Sovet Ministrov SSSR, 1945 – 1953. Rosspen, Moskva. Kornai, János, 1980.Economics of shortage. North-Holland, Amsterdam. Kornai, János, Eric Maskin and Gerard Roland, 2003. Understanding the Soft Budget Constraint. Journal of Economic Literature, 41(4), 1095-1136. Lazarev, Valery, and Paul Gregory, 2002. The Wheels of a Command Economy: Allocating Soviet Vehicles. Economic History Review, 55(2), 324-48. Lazarev, Valery and Paul Gregory, 2003. Commissars and cars: A case study in the political economy of dictatorship, Journal of Comparative Economics, 31(1), 1-19. Markevich, Andrei, 2003. Byla li sovetskaia ekonomika planovoi? Planirovanie v narkomatakh v 1930-e gg. [Was the Soviet Economy Planned? Planning in the Ministries in the 1930s]. In: Ekonomicheskaia istoriia. Ezhegodnik. 2003 [Economic History Yearbook, 2003]. Rosspen, Moskva. Markevich, Andrei, 2007. How Much Control is Enough? Monitoring and Interventions in Stalin’s Command. Economy. Mimeo. Mises, Ludwig von, 1920/1935. Die Wirtschaftsrechnung im sozialistischen Gemeinwesen, translated in: F.A. Hayek (Ed.) Collectivist Economic Planning Critical Studies on the Possibility of Socialism. Routledge, London, pp. 87-130. Rees, E. A., 1987. State control in Soviet Russia: the rise and fall of the Workers’ and Peasants’ Inspectorate, 1920-34. St. Martin Press, New York. Rees, E.A. (Ed.), 1997. Decision-Making in the Stalinist Economy, 1932-1937. St. Martin Press, New York. Simonov, Nikolai S., 1996. Voenno-promyshlennyi kompleks SSSR v 1920-1950-e gody: tempy ekonomicheskogo rosta, struktura, organizatsiia proizvodstva i upravlenie. Rosspen, Moskva. Solomon, Peter, 1996. Soviet criminal justice under Stalin. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Wintrobe, Ronald, 1998. The political economy of dictatorship. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Wintrobe, Ronald, 2001. How to understand, and deal with dictatorship: an economic view. Economics of Governance, 2, 35-58. Archival: Hoover/RGANI: “Archives of the Former Soviet State and Communist Party’ from the Russian State Archives of Recent History (Moscow) at the Hoover Institution of War, Revolution, and Peace (Stanford, CA). Hoover/RGASPI: “Archives of the Former Soviet State and Communist Party’ from the Russian State Archives of Social and Political History (Moscow) at the Hoover Institution of War, Revolution, and Peace (Stanford, CA). GARF – State archive of Russian Federation (Moscow). Russian archival documents are numbered according to a standard system: collection (fond), inventory (opis), file (delo), folio (list).
URI:	http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/id/eprint/1400

Request changes to a record

Actions (login required)

View Item