Harrison, Mark, 1949- (2003) How much did the Soviets really spend on defence? New evidence from the close of the Brezhnev era. Working Paper. University of Warwick, Department of Economics, Coventry.

Preview

PDF WRAP_Harrison_twerp662.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader Download (326Kb)

Abstract

The paper considers the influence of the budget for military spending in the Soviet command economy. A specific problem is that the Soviet strategy of concealment left us without good measures of the military burden on Societ resources. The paper surveys previous western attempts to fill this gap alongside post-Brezhnev revelations. A new documentary source from 1982 that appears authoritative suggests much higher figures than anything proposed or revealed so far, and supports these higher figures in detail. However, the figures contain many puzzles and the authenticity of the document itself cannot be fully assured.

Item Type:	Working or Discussion Paper (Working Paper)
Subjects:	H Social Sciences > HC Economic History and Conditions D History General and Old World > DK Russia. Soviet Union. Former Soviet Republics
Divisions:	Faculty of Social Sciences > Economics
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):	Brezhnev, Leonid Il'ich, 1906-1982, Soviet Union -- Armed Forces -- Appropriations and expenditures, Soviet Union -- Appropriations and expenditures, Soviet Union -- History -- 1953-1985, Soviet Union -- History, Military, Soviet Union -- Economic policy -- 1965-1975, Soviet Union -- Economic policy -- 1975-1985
Series Name:	Warwick economic research papers
Publisher:	University of Warwick, Department of Economics
Place of Publication:	Coventry
Date:	3 January 2003
Number:	No.662
Number of Pages:	41
Status:	Not Peer Reviewed
Access rights to Published version:	Open Access
References:	Abelshauser, Werner (1998), “Germany: Guns, Butter, and Economic Miracles”, in Mark Harrison, ed., The Economics of World War II: Six Great Powers in International Comparison, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 122–76 Anderton, Charles H. (1993), “Arms Race Modelling and Economic Growth”, in James E. Payne and Anandi P. Sahu, eds, Defense Spending and Economic Growth, Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 55–82 Barber, John, Mark Harrison, N.S. Simonov, and B.S. Starkov (2000), “The Structure and Development of the Defence–Industry Complex”, in John Barber and Mark Harrison, eds, The Soviet Defence–Industry Complex from Stalin to Khrushchev, London and Basingstoke: Macmillan, 3–29 Becker, Abraham S. (1964), Soviet Military Outlays since 1958, Santa Monica, CA: The RAND Corporation, RM–3886–PR Bergson, Abram (1948), “Russian Defense Expenditures”, Foreign Affairs, 26(2), 373–6 Burton, Donald F. (1983), “Estimating Soviet Defense Spending”, Problems of Communism, 32(2), 85–93 CEC et al. (1993): Commission of the European Communities, International Monetary Fund, Organisation for Economic Co–operation and Development, United Nations, World Bank, System of National Accounts 1993, Brussels/Luxembourg– New York, NY–Paris–Washington, DC CIA (1976): United States Central Intelligence Agency, Estimated Soviet Defense Spending in Rubles, 1970–1975, SR76-10121U, Washington, DC: US GPO CIA (1990): United States Central Intelligence Agency, Measures of Soviet Gross National Product in 1982 Prices, Washington, DC: US GPO Cooper, Julian (1998), “The Military Expenditure of the USSR and the Russian Federation, 1987–97”, in SIPRI Yearbook 1998, Stockholm: Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, 243–56 Davies, R.W. (1958), The Development of the Soviet Budgetary System, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Davies, R.W, Melanie Ilič, and Oleg Khlevniuk (2002), “Stalin, the Politburo and Economic Policy”, University of Birmingham, Centre for Russian and East European Studies. Davies, R.W. (1993), “Soviet Military Expenditure and the Armaments Industry, 1929–33: a Reconsideration”, Europe–Asia Studies, 45(4), 577–608 Davies, R.W. (2001), “Making Economic Policy”, in Paul R. Gregory, ed., Behind the Façade of Stalin’s Command Economy, Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press, 61–80 Davies, R.W., and Mark Harrison (1997), “The Soviet Military–Economic Effort under the Second Five–Year Plan (1933–1937)”, Europe–Asia Studies, 49(3), 369–406 Davis, Christopher (2002, “The Defence Sector in the Economy of a Declining Superpower: Soviet Union and Russia, 1965–2000”, Defence and Peace Economics, forthcoming Doe, Frank (1982), “Understanding the Soviet View of Military Expenditures”, US Defence Intelligence Agency, Paper prepared for the Joint Economic Committee/Congressional Research Service Duchêne, Gerard (1987), “How Much Do the Soviets Spend on Defence?”, in Carl G. Jacobsen, ed., The Soviet Defence Enigma: Estimating Costs and Burden, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 95–115 Duchêne, Gerard, and Dmitri Steinberg, (1987), “Soviet National Accounts”, in Carl G. Jacobsen, ed., The Soviet Defence Enigma: Estimating Costs and Burden, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 11–23 Easterly, William, and Stanley Fischer (1995), “The Soviet Economic Decline”, World Bank Economic Review, 9(3), 341–71 Eloranta, Jari (2002), “The Demand for External Security by Domestic Choices: Military Spending as an Impure Public Good Among Eleven European States, 1920–1938”, PhD Dissertation, European University Institute, San Domenico di Fiesole Epstein, David F. (1990), “The Economic Cost of Soviet Security and Empire”, in Henry S. Rowen and Charles Wolf, eds, The Impoverished Superpower: Perestroika and the Soviet Military Burden, San Francisco, CA: Institute for Contemporary Studies, 127–54 Evans, Richard J. (2002), Telling Lies About Hitler: The Holocaust, History, and the David Irving Trial, London: Verso Firth, Noel E., and James H. Noren (1998), Soviet Defense Spending: a History of CIA Estimates, 1950–1990, College Station, TX: Texas A & M University Press Gams, E., and V. Makarenko (1990), “Razmyshleniia o rakhodakh obshchestva na oboronu, voennom biudzhete i biudzhete ministerstva oborony”, Voprosy ekonomiki, no. 10 (October), 149–53 Garvy, George (1977), Money, Financial Flows, and Credit in the Soviet Union, Cambridge, MA: Ballinger and National Bureau of Economic Research Gorbachev, Mikhail (1996), Memoirs, London: Doubleday Goskomstat SSSR (1987), Narodnoe khoziaistvo SSSR za 70 let. Iubileinyi statisticheskii ezhegodnik, Moscow: Finansy i Statistika Goskomstat SSSR (1990), Narodnoe khoziaistvo SSSR v 1989 godu. Statisticheskii ezhegodnik, Moscow: Finansy i Statistika Gregory, Paul R. (2001); “The Dictator’s Orders”, in Paul R. Gregory, ed., Behind the Façade of Stalin’s Command Economy, Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press, 11–34 Gregory, Paul R. (2002), “Why Was Soviet Defense Planning So Far Off the Mark?”, University of Houston, Department of Economics Harrison, Mark (1990), “The Volume of Soviet Munitions Output, 1937–1945: A Reevaluation, Journal of Economic History, 50(3), 569–89 Harrison, Mark (1996), Accounting for War: Soviet Production, Employment, and the Defence Burden, 1940–1945, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, Harrison, Mark (1998), “The Economics of World War II: an Overview”, in Mark Harrison, ed., The Economics of World War II: Six Great Powers in International Comparison, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1–42 Harrison, Mark (2002), “Economic Growth and Slowdown”, in Edwin Bacon and Mark Sandle, eds, Brezhnev Reconsidered, Basingstoke and London: Palgrave, 38–67 Harrison, Mark, and Byung–Yeon Kim (2001), “Plan, Siphoning, and Corruption in the Soviet Command Economy”, University of Warwick, Department of Economics The Warwick Economics Research Paper Series no. 606 Holzman, Franklyn D. (1980), “Are the Soviets Really Outspending the U.S. on Defense?”, International Security, 4(4), 86–104 Kennedy, Paul (1988), The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers : Economic Change and Military Conflict from 1500 to 2000, London: Unwin Khlevniuk, O.V., I. Gorlitskii [Yoram Gorlizki], L.P. Kosheleva, A.I. Miniuk, M.Iu. Prozumenshchikov, L.A. Rogovaia, and S.V. Somonova, eds (2002), Politbiuro TsK VPK(b) i Sovet Ministrov SSSR. 1945–1953, Moscow: ROSSPen Konoplev, B.V. (1981), Otchet Voenno-promyshlennoi komissii VS SSSR TsK KPSS ob ispol’zovanii assignovanii na oborony za piatiletku (1976–1981 gg.), typescript photocopy: URL http://www.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/staff/faculty/harrison/papers/konoplev.pdf Konoplev, B.V. (2002), “Bylo tak, kak ia govoriu” and “Zdes’ ia ne zabyt”, Novyi kompan’on, nos 8(204) and 9(205), Perm’, 12 and 19 March: URL http://nk.kama.ru/ Kontorovich, Vladimir (1988), “The Soviet Investment Process and Capital–Labor Substitution”, in John P. Hardt and Carl H. MacMillan, eds, Planned Economies: Confronting the Challenges of the 1980s, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 13–27 Landau, Daniel (1993), “The Economic Impact of Military Expenditures”, The World Bank: Washington, DC, Policy Research Working Paper no. 1138 Lee, William T. (1977), The Estimation of Soviet Military Expenditures, 1955-1977: an Unconventional Approach, New York: Praeger Lee, William T. (1995), CIA Estimates of Soviet Military Expenditures: Errors and Waste, An Intelligence Oversight Study, Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research Masliukov, Iu.D., and E.S. Glubokov (1999), “Planirovanie i finansirovanie voennoi promyshlennosti v SSSR”, in A.V. Minaev, ed., Sovetskaia voennaia moshch’ ot Stalina do Gorbacheva, Moscow: Voennyi parad, 82–129 Michaud, Norbert D. (1990), “The Paradox of Current Soviet Military Spending”, in Henry S. Rowen and Charles Wolf, eds, The Impoverished Superpower: Perestroika and the Soviet Military Burden, San Francisco, CA: Institute for Contemporary Studies, 111–26 Minaev, A.V. (1999), “Istoki sovetskoi voennoi moshchi”, in A.V. Minaev, ed., Sovetskaia voennaia moshch’ ot Stalina do Gorbacheva, Moscow: Voennyi parad, 18–35 Mochizuki Kiichi (1987), “Estimating Soviet Defence Expenditures From National Accounts”, in Carl G. Jacobsen, ed., The Soviet Defence Enigma: Estimating Costs and Burden, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 117–35 Noren, James H. (1995), “The Controversy Over Western Measures of Soviet Defense Expenditures”, Post–Soviet Affairs, 11(3), 238–76 Overy, R.J. (1994), War and Economy in the Third Reich, Oxford: Oxford University Press Plotnikov, K.N. (1945), Biudzhet sovetskogo gosudarstva, Moscow: Gosfinizdat Rosefielde, Steven (1982/87), False Science: Underestimating the Soviet Arms Buildup. An Appraisal of the CIA’s Direct Costing Effort, 1960–1980, New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books, first edn; False Science: Underestimating the Soviet Arms Buildup. An Appraisal of the CIA’s Direct Costing Effort, 1960–1985, New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books, second edn Rosefielde, Steven (1990), “Soviet Defence Spending: the Contribution of the New Accountancy”, Soviet Studies, 42(1), 59-80 Steinberg, Dmitri (1987), “Estimating Total Soviet Military Expenditures: An Alternative Approach Based on Reconstructed Soviet National Accounts”, in Carl G. Jacobsen, ed., The Soviet Defence Enigma: Estimating Costs and Burden, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 27–57 Steinberg, Dmitri (1990a), “Trends in Soviet Military Expenditure”, Soviet Studies, 42(4), 675–699 Steinberg, Dmitri (1990b), The Soviet Economy, 1970-1990: a Statistical Analysis, San Francisco, CA: International Trade Press Steinberg, Dmitri (1992), “The Soviet Defence Burden: Estimating Hidden Defence Costs”, Europe–Asia Studies, 44(2), 237–63 Swain, D. Derk (1990), “The Soviet Military Sector: How It is Defined and Measured”, in Henry S. Rowen and Charles Wolf, eds, The Impoverished Superpower: Perestroika and the Soviet Military Burden, San Francisco, CA: Institute for Contemporary Studies, 93–110 Terpilovskii, M.V. (1967), ed., Finansovaia sluzhba Vooruzhennykh Sil SSSR v period voiny, Moscow: Voenizdat TsSU (1981): Tsentral’noe Statisticheskoe Upravlenie SSSR, Narodnoe khoziaistvo SSSR v 1980 god. Statisticheskii ezhegodnik. Moscow: Finansy i statistika TsSU (1982): Tsentral’noe Statisticheskoe Upravlenie SSSR, Narodnoe khoziaistvo SSSR. 1922– 1982. Iubileinyi statisticheskii ezhegodnik. Moscow: Finansy i statistika UN (2000): United Nations, Classification of Expenditures According to Purpose, New York, NY: United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Statistics Division, Statistical Papers, Series M No. 84 Voznesenskii, N.A. (1947), Voennaia ekonomika SSSR v period Otechestvennoi voiny, Moscow: Gospolitizdat Wiles, P.J.D. (1987), “How Soviet Defence Expenditure Fits into the National Income Accounts”, in Carl G. Jacobsen, ed., The Soviet Defence Enigma: Estimating Costs and Burden, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 59–94 Wiles, P.J.D., and Moshe Efrat, (1985), The Economics of Soviet Arms (Some Probable Magnitudes), London: London School of Economics, Suntory Toyota International Centre for Economics and Related Disciplines Wolfson, Murray (1985), “Notes on Economic Warfare”, Conflict Management and Peace Science, 8(2), 1–20
URI:	http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/id/eprint/1527

Request changes to a record

Actions (login required)

View Item