
The Library
The demand for contrastive explanations
Tools
Elzein, Nadine (2019) The demand for contrastive explanations. Philosophical Studies, 176 (5). pp. 1325-1339. doi:10.1007/s11098-018-1065-z ISSN 0031-8116.
Research output not available from this repository.
Request-a-Copy directly from author or use local Library Get it For Me service.
Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11098-018-1065-z
Abstract
A “contrastive explanation” explains not only why some event A occurred, but why A occurred as opposed to some alternative event B. Some philosophers argue that agents could only be morally responsible for their choices if those choices have contrastive explanations, since they would otherwise be “luck infested”. Assuming that contrastive explanations cannot be offered for causally undetermined events, this requirement entails that no one could be held responsible for a causally undetermined choice. Such arguments challenge incompatibilism, since they entail that causal determinism is a prerequisite for moral responsibility. However, I argue that for a significant class of choices, even if we stipulate that they are determined, we will be unable to provide a relevant contrastive explanation. Hence causal determinism is no remedy for luck infestation, and compatibilists do not fare much better than incompatibilists in the face of this requirement. This should serve to weaken its philosophical appeal.
Item Type: | Journal Article | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Divisions: | Faculty of Social Sciences > Philosophy | ||||||
Journal or Publication Title: | Philosophical Studies | ||||||
Publisher: | Springer | ||||||
ISSN: | 0031-8116 | ||||||
Official Date: | May 2019 | ||||||
Dates: |
|
||||||
Volume: | 176 | ||||||
Number: | 5 | ||||||
Page Range: | pp. 1325-1339 | ||||||
DOI: | 10.1007/s11098-018-1065-z | ||||||
Status: | Peer Reviewed | ||||||
Publication Status: | Published | ||||||
Access rights to Published version: | Open Access (Creative Commons) |
Request changes or add full text files to a record
Repository staff actions (login required)
![]() |
View Item |