Globalisation, regionalisation & the Americas. The free trade area of the Americas: fuelling the 'race to the bottom'?
MacLeod, A. (Alexander) (2005) Globalisation, regionalisation & the Americas. The free trade area of the Americas: fuelling the 'race to the bottom'? Working Paper. University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation, Coventry.
WRAP_Macleod_wp17705.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
Official URL: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/csgr/research/wo...
The framing of the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) over a period of ten years is a project on a unique scale and with a unique significance. According to Robert Devlin, the FTAA is undoubtedly the most ambitious collective economic initiative in the history of the Western Hemisphere. The intention is to create the biggest market in the world, comprising 800 million people and a GDP of US$11 - 14 trillion. If it is successful, it will also bring to conclusion ten years of negotiation and bilateral and sub-regional trade agreements that will be essentially subsumed in the FTAA. However, prospects for finalising the Agreement look slim as negotiations on the scope and scale of the FTAA have reached an impasse when the January 2005 deadline passed without consensus. The failure to complete the Agreement raises significant questions about the raison d’etre of regional agreements, the relationship between globalisation and regionalism, and the balance between free trade and social interests. The debate surrounding the FTAA presents a particularly interesting illustration of the arguments for and against free trade agreements generally -- first, for their historic place in the global pattern and context of regionalisation within the Americas; second, for the issues raised by the current impasse. This paper explores the inherent flaws in the FTAA and how it might have potentially negative impacts on the region in terms of social, economic, environmental and political outcomes. The first part of this paper looks at the global and regional context of the FTAA and the growth of regionalism, mediated by the US and the EU. The second part looks at how regionalism and free trade, working through the FTAA, are seen to have serious drawbacks, which have generated a range of opposition, and led to the frustration of negotiations. This paper also questions whether, given the experience of NAFTA (North American Free Trade Area), the model itself is flawed; and whether the FTAA, in its far wider scope and significance for the Americas, will in effect fuel a ‘race to the bottom’. The final question is whether the situation can be retrieved, and whether changes to the FTAA, enabling it to promote economic, social and human development, will in fact be put in place.
|Item Type:||Working or Discussion Paper (Working Paper)|
|Alternative Title:||Globalisation, regionalisation and the Americas. The free trade area of the Americas: fuelling the 'race to the bottom'?|
|Subjects:||H Social Sciences > HB Economic Theory
J Political Science > JZ International relations
|Divisions:||Faculty of Social Sciences > Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation|
|Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):||Free Trade Area of the Americas (Organization), MERCOSUR (Organization), European Union, Economic development -- South America, Regionalism (International organization), Globalization -- Economic aspects, Civil society|
|Series Name:||Working papers (University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation)|
|Publisher:||University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation|
|Place of Publication:||Coventry|
|Number of Pages:||22|
|Status:||Not Peer Reviewed|
|Access rights to Published version:||Open Access|
|References:||US/EU/Latin American Free Trade Agreements Arnaud, G, MERCOSUR, Unión Europea, Nafta y los procesos de Integración Regional, (Abeledo-Perrot, Buenos Aires, 1996). Arocena, M, Common Market of the Southern Cone: MERCOSUR: The Impact of Economic Integration: A Case study. (ILO, Geneva, 1997). Barenberg, M and Evans, P, ‘The FTAAs Impact on Democratic Governance’ in Estevadeordal A, Rodrik, D, Taylor, A and Velasco, A, (eds) , Integrating the Americas: FTAA and Beyond, (Harvard University Press, 2004). Bizzozoso, L and Vaillent, M, (eds), La Insercion Internacional del MERCOSUR: Mirando al Sur o Mirando al Norte?, (ARCA, Montevideo, 1996). Bulmer-Thomas, Victor (ed.) Regional Integration in Latin America and the Caribbean: The Political Economy of Open Regionalism, (Institute of Latin American Studies, 2001). Bulmer-Thomas, Victor and James Dunkerley (eds.) The United States and Latin America: The New Agenda, (Institute for Latin American Studies / Rockefeller Centre for Latin American Studies, 1999). Bustillo, I and Ocampo, J. A, ‘Asymmetries and Cooperation in the FTAA’, in Estevadeordal A, Rodrik, D, Taylor, A and Velasco, A, (eds) Integrating the Americas: FTAA and Beyond (Harvard University Press, 2004). Chambers, E and Peter S (eds.) NAFTA in the New Millennium, (University of California / University of Alberta, 2002). Coote, B, NAFTA: Poverty and Free Trade in Mexico, (Oxfam Publications, UK, 1995). Echeverri-Carroll, E, (ed), NAFTA and Trade Liberalization in the Americas, (Bureau of Business Research, Graduate School of Business, IC2 Institute, University of Texas at Austin, USA, 1995). De Block, C and Turcotte, S, ‘La Zone de Libre Exchange dans Amériques : Les Etats-Unis Seuls Maîtres à Bord?’ In, Santander, S, (ed), Globalisation, Gouvernance et Logiques Régionales dans les Amériques, (Universite Libre de Bruselles, Cahiers du GELA-IS, 2004) Elliot, K, 'Labour Standards in the FTAA' in Estevadeordal A, Rodrik, D, Taylor, A and Velasco, A, (eds), Integrating the Americas: FTAA and Beyond, (Harvard University Press, 2004). Esty, D, ‘The Environmental Dimension of Economic Integration: The FTAA and Beyond’ in Estevadeordal A, Rodrik, D, Taylor, A and Velasco, A, (eds), Integrating the Americas: FTAA and Beyond, (Harvard University Press, 2004). Ffrench-Davies, R, The Andean Pact, A Model of Economic Integration for Developing Countries, (Center for Latin American Development Studies, Boston University, 1976). Flecker, K, FTAA: A Gamble Staked against Migrant Communities, (Polaris Institute, 2000). Grugel, Jean and Wil Hout (eds.) Regionalism Across the North-South Divide: State Strategies and Globalisation, (Routledge, 1999). Hoebing, J, Weintraub, S and Delal Baer M, (eds) NAFTA and Sovereignty: Trade-Offs for Canada, Mexico, and the United States, (Center for Strategic & International Studies, Washington, D.C, 1996). Khosrow, F, (ed) North American Free Trade Agreement: Opportunities and Challenges (Macmillan, Basingstoke, 1993). Lombaerde P De, Integración Asimétrica y Convergencia Económica en las Américas, (Universidad Nacional de Colombia, 2002). Lopez-Calva, L. E, and Lustig, N, Social Protection and Inclusive Trade: Strengthening the Sources of Convergence’ in Estevadeordal A, Rodrik, D, Taylor, A and Velasco, A, (eds), Integrating the Americas: FTAA and Beyond, (Harvard University Press, 2004). Pastor, R, Exiting the Whirlpool: U.S. Foreign Policy Toward Latin America and the Caribbean , (Westview, 2001). Payne, A, ‘The United States and its Enterprise for the Americas’, in Gamble, A and Payne, A, (eds.) Regionalism and World Order , (Macmillan, Basingstoke,1996). Roett, R (ed.) MERCOSUR:Regional Integration, World Markets , (Lynne Rienner, 1999). Schott, J (ed), Free Trade Areas and U.S. Tra de Policy, (Institute for International Economics, Washington, D.C. 1989) . Smith, P, Talons of the Eagle: Dynamics of US-Latin American Relations, (Oxford University Press, 2000). Vizentini, P and Wiesebron, M, (eds) Free Trade for the Americas?: The United States' push for the FTAA Agreement, (Zed Books, New York, 2004). Weintraub, S, Development and Democracy in the Southern Cone: Imperatives for US Policy in South America , (CSIS Press, 2000). Wilson Nerys, F, Mercosur, Estados Unidos, ALCA: Globalización y Regionalización en el Cambio de Siglo, (Findación de Cultura Universitaria, Montevideo, 2000). Globalisation, Regionalism and International Relations Aggarwal, V and Fogarty E, (eds) EU Trade Strategies: Between Regionalism and Globalization, (Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2004). Beck, U, What is Globalisation? (Polity, Cambridge, 2002) Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo, Tratados, regulaciones y organización del mercado común entre Argentina, Brasil, Uruguay y Paraguay (MERCOSUR), (Instituto para la Integración de América Latina, Buenos Aires,1992). Bright, C, The EU: Understanding the Brussels Process, Chichester, Wiley, UK, 1995 Coleman, W D and Underhill, G (eds) Regionalism and Global Economic Integration: Europe, Asia and the Americas, (Routledge, 1998). Demaret,P , Bellis, J-F and, Gonzalo García, J, Regionalism and Multilateralism after the Uruguay round: Convergence, Divergence and Interaction,, (European Interuniversity Press, Brussels, 1997). Domínguez, Jorge (ed.) The Future of Inter -American Relations, (Routledge, 2000). European Commission, Directorate-General for External Relations, European Union relations with the United States, (Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, 2002). Lawson, S, The New Agenda for International Relations, (Polity, Cambridge, 2002). Mitchell, J and McAleavey, P, Regionalism and Regional Policy in the European Union: (Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2003). Mofid, K, Globalisation for the Common Good, (Shepheard-Walwyn, London, 2002). Scott, J, W, ‘Regional Development and Cooperation on the US/Mexican Border’, in, Perkmann, M and Ngai-Ling, S, Globalisation, Regionalisation and Cross-Border Regions, (Palgrave, London, 2002). Soloaga, I and Winters, A, Regionalism in the Nineties: What Effect on Trade?, (Centre for Economic Policy Research, London, 1999). Teunissen, J, (ed) Regionalism and the global economy : the case of Latin America and the Caribbean,Seminar on Regional Economic Integration and Global Economic Cooperation (Santiago de Chile), (Forum on Debt and Development (FONDAD), The Hague, 1995). Wyatt-Walter, A, Regionalism, Globalism and World Economic Order, (Oxford University Press, 1995). Journals, reports and papers Behar, J, ‘Measuring the Effects of Economic Integration for the Southern Cone Countries: Industry Simulations of Trade Liberalisation,’ Developing Economics, 33 (1), 4-31, 1995. Brown, D, Deardorff, A and Stern, R, ‘Expanding NAFTA: Economic Effects of Accession of Chile and Other Major South American Nations,’ North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 6 (2), 149-170, 1995. Defraigne, P, Deputy Director General DG Trade, European Commission, ‘New Regionalism and Global Economic Governance’, published in UNU/CRIS e-Working papers, Bruges, 2002. Devlin, R, ‘The Free Trade Area of the Americas and MERCOSUR-EU Free Trade Processes: Can they Learn Something from Each Other?’, Inter American Development Bank, Occasional Paper 6, 2000 Devlin, R and Ffrench-Davis, R, ‘Towards an Evaluation of Regional Integration in Latin America in the 1990s,’ World Economy, 22 (2), March, 1999. Diao, X and Somwaru, A, ‘A Dynamic Evaluation of the Effects of a Free Trade Area of the Americas: An Intertemporal World Model,’ Journal of Economic Integration, 22 (5) 557-588, 2001. Farrell, M, ‘The EU and Inter Regional Cooperation: In Search of Global Presence?’ e-Working Papers, W-2004/9, UNU-CRIS, Bruges, 2004 Feinberg, R, E., ‘Regionalism and Domestic Politics: US-Latin American Trade Policy in the Bush Era’, Latin American Politics and Society, 44:1 (2002). Grugel, J, ‘Civil Society and Inclusion in New Regionalism: Can Civil Society Influence a Trade-led Agenda?’ Paper prepared for the second annual conference of the Euro-Latin trade network, Florence, 2002 Inter American Development Bank, 2002 Report: ‘Beyond Borders: the New Regionalism in Latin Americas’, Washington DC, 2002 Pederson, T, ‘Cooperative Hegemony: Power, Ideas and Institutions in regional integration’, Review of International Studies, 28 (4): 677-696, 2000. Mackay, D, ‘Challenges Confronting the Free Trade Area of the Americas’, Policy Paper, Canadian Foundation for the Americas (FOCAL), 2002. Monteagudo, J and Watanuki, M, ‘Regional Trade Agreements for MERCOSUR: the FTAA and the FTA with the European Union’, Paper prepared for presentation at the Conference “Impacts of Trade Liberalisation Agreements on Latin America and the Caribbean’, organised by the IDB and the Centres de d’Etudes Prospectives et d’information Internationales, November 5-6 2001, Washington D.C, 2001. San Sebastian, M and Hurtig, A, ‘Moving on from NAFTA to the FTAA?: The Impact of Trade Agreements on Social and Public Health Conditions in the Americas’, in Revista Pan Americana de Salud Publica/Pan America Public Heath Review , 16 (4), 2004 Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade, ‘The Free Trade Area of the Americas : towards a hemispheric agreement in the Canadian interest’: first report of: first report of the Sub-Committee on International Trade, Trade Disputes and Investment. Corporate Name: Canada. Parliament. House of Commons. Sub-Committee on International Trade, Trade Disputes and Investment, Public Works and Government Services Canada, Ottawa, 1999. Williamson, J. ‘What Should the World Bank Think About the Washington Consensus?’ World Bank Research Observer. Washington, DC: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Vol. 15, No. 2 (August 2000), pp. 251-264. Wonnacott, P and Wonnacott R, ‘Liberalization in the Western Hemisphere: New Challenges in the Design of a Free Trade Agreement,’ North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 6 (2), 107-119, 1995 Interviews Andres Mongaldo, Political Sectretary, Educadoran Embassay, Brussels, 11 March 2005. Hernan Escobar, Political Attaché, Venezuelan Embassy, Brussels, 15 April 2005|
Actions (login required)