The globalization of management consultancy firms: constraints and limitations
Morgan, Glenn, Sturdy, Andrew and Quack, Sigrid (2006) The globalization of management consultancy firms: constraints and limitations. Working Paper. University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation, Coventry.
WRAP_Morgan_wp16805.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
Official URL: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/csgr/research/wo...
This paper is aimed at providing a framework for the analysis of organizational structures and processes in the global management consulting industry. Our basic question is why do global consulting firms exist? What distinctive advantages (if any) are they able to bring to their clients and the consulting task which cannot be achieved by ‘national’ firms? Consideration of this question leads us into alternative modes of internationalisation in this sector. Economists in the field of international business have long posed this question in relation to manufacturing firms (e.g. Dunning 1993). However, their answers tend to be limited to economic considerations and ignore the ways in which issues of organizational structure, power and processes impact on the internationalising strategies of firms. More recently other authors have posed the same question specifically in relation to professional services firms (Aharonhi 2000: Lowendahl 2000; Nachum 2000; Roberts 1998; 1999; 2004). These authors have argued that there are specific characteristics of professional services that require an adaptation of the dominant models of internationalisation. These relate to the distinctive interface between clients and suppliers in these contexts where co-presence and interaction is typically essential. This interaction in conditions where knowledge is ambiguous and/or clients may be less ‘knowledgeable’ than the professionals about the nature and quality of the services delivered has tended also to lead to national regulatory regimes controlling how some professional services are delivered, monitored and controlled. These factors have tended to militate against the globalization of professional services. However, in recent years, the development of professional services outside strong regulatory frameworks of practice (such as in the case of management consultancies and advertising agencies), the gradual decline of national regulatory regimes under pressures of ‘free trade’ and the increased international standardisation of certain forms of professional services (such as audits) has opened up more possibilities for the internationalisation of firms in this area. The general phenomenon of what Giddens (1990) has labelled ‘time-space distanciation’ in theory makes it easier to both maintain communication and control across widely spread national contexts and also to facilitate forms of cross-national team-building and cooperation. For all these reasons, the services sector in general and professional services in particular has seen a massive expansion of international activity over the last two decades. Bryson et al, for example state that ‘the value of world commercial services exports has increased some 3.5 times between 1980 and 1999’ (Bryson et al. 2004: 217). The 2004 World Investment Report from UNCTAD noted that ‘on average, services accounted for two-thirds of total FDI inflows during 2001-2, valued at some $500 billion’ (UNCTAD 2004: xx). Interestingly, the report went on to state that ‘as the transnationalization of the services sector in home and host countries lags behind that of manufacturing, there is scope for a further shift towards services’ (ibid.). This suggests that the organizational issues concerned with the internationalization of service firms have not disappeared. It is these organizational issues which lie at the heart of our concerns.
|Item Type:||Working or Discussion Paper (Working Paper)|
|Subjects:||J Political Science > JZ International relations
H Social Sciences > HD Industries. Land use. Labor
|Divisions:||Faculty of Social Sciences > Warwick Business School
Faculty of Social Sciences > Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation
|Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):||Organizational change, Business consultants, Globalization -- Economic aspects, International business enterprises|
|Series Name:||Working papers (University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation)|
|Publisher:||University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation|
|Place of Publication:||Coventry|
|Number of Pages:||46|
|Status:||Not Peer Reviewed|
|Access rights to Published version:||Open Access|
|References:||Aharoni, Y. (2000) The role of reputation in global professional business services. In: Aharoni, Y. and Nachum, L., (Eds.) Globalization of Services, pp. 125-141. London: Routledge Aharoni, Y. and Nachum, L. (2000) Globalization of Services, London: Routledge. Alvesson, M. (2000) Social Identity and the Problem of Loyalty in Knowledge-Intensive Companies Journal of Management Studies 37,8, pp.1101-1123) Alvesson, M. (2001) Knowledge work: ambiguity, image and identity. Human Relations 54, 863-886. Alvesson, M. and Karreman, D. (2004a) Cages in Tandem: Management control, social identity and identification in a knowledge-intensive firm. Organization 11, 149-175. Alvesson, M. and Karreman, D. (2004b) Interfaces of control. Technocratic and socio-ideological control in a global management consultancy firm. Accounting, Organizations and Society 29, 423-444. Armbruster, T. (2004) Rationality and its symbols: signalling effects and subjectification in management consulting. Journal of Management Studies 41, 1247-1269. Arnold, P. (2004) Disciplining domestic regulation: the World Trade Organization and the market for professional services Accounting, Organizations and Society 30, 299-330. Backlund, J. and Werr, A. (2004) The construction of global management consulting - a study of consultancies' web presentations. In: Buono, A.F., (Ed.) Creative Consulting: Innovative Perspectives on Management Consulting, Greenwich,CT: Information Age Publishing Barrett, M., Cooper, D. and Jamal, K. (2005) Globalization and the coordinating of work in multinational audits. Accounting, Organizations and Society 30, 1- 24. Bartlett, C. A., and Ghoshal, S. (1989). Managing across Borders: The Transnational Solution. London: Century Business. Beaverstock, J. (2004) ‘Managing across Borders’: knowledge management and expatriation in professional service legal firms Journal of Economic Geography 4, pp.157-179. Beaverstock, J., Smith, R.G., Taylor, P. (2000) Geographies of Globalization: US Law Firms in World Cities Urban Geography, 21, 2, pp.95-120. Beaverstock, J., Smith, R.G., Taylor, P. (1999) The Long Arm of the Law: London’s Law Firms in a Globalizing World Economy Environment and Planning A, 31, 10, pp.1857-1876. Belanger, J., Berggren, C., Bjorkman, T., and Kohler, C. (1999). Being Local and Worldwide: ABB and the Challenge of Global Management. Ithaca, NY: ILR imprint, Cornell University Press. Birkinshaw, J. (1997). ‘Entrepreneurship in Multinational Corporations: The Characteristics of Subsidiary Initiatives’. Strategic Management Journal, 18: 207–29. —— (2000). Entrepreneurship in the Global Firm. London: Sage. —— (2001). ‘Strategy and Management in MNE Subsidiaries’, in A. Rugman and T. L. Brewer (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of International Business. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Botzem, S. and Quack, S. (forthcoming) ‘Contested Rules and Shifting Boundaries: International Standard Setting in Accounting’, in Djelic, M.-L. and Sahlin-Andersson, K. (eds.), Transnational regulations in the making. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Brock.D., Powell, M. and Hinings, C.R. (1999) Restructuring the professional organization, London: Routledge. Bryson, J.R., Daniels, P.W. and Warf, B. (2004) Service Worlds: People, Organisations, Technologies, London: Routledge. Castells, M. (1996) The rise of the network society, Oxford: Blackwells. Clark, T. and Fincham, R. (2002) Critical Consulting: New Perspectives on the Management Advice Industry, Oxford: Blackwell. Clark, T. (1995) Managing Consultants, Buckingham: Open University Press. Dezelay, Y. and Garth, B.(1996) Dealing in Virtue Chicago; University of Chicago Press. Dezelay, Y. and Garth, B. (2002a). The Internationalization of Palace Wars. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Dezelay, Y. and Garth, B. (eds.) (2002b). Global Prescriptions. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Djelic, M-L. (1998). Exporting the American Model. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Dunford, R. (2000) Key challenges in the search for the effective management of knowledge in management consulting firms. Journal of Knowledge Management 4, 295-302. Dunning, J. (1993) The Globalization of Business, London: Routledge. Dunning, J. (1993) The globalization of service activities. In: Dunning, J., Globalization of Business, pp. 242-284. London: Routledge Empson, L. (2001) Fear of exploitation and fear of contamination: impediments to knowledge transfer in mergers between professional service firms. Human Relations 54, 839-862. Fenton, E.M. and Pettigrew, A.M. (2003) Complementary change: towards global integration in four professional service organizations. In: Pettigrew, A.M., Whittington, R., Melin, L., Sanchez-Runde.C., van den Bosch, F., Ruoigok, W. and Numagami, T., (Eds.) Innovative forms of organizing, pp. 208-239. London: Sage Fenton, E.M. and Pettigrew, A.M. (2000) The role of scoial mechanisms in an emerging network: the case of the pharmaceutical network in Coopers & Lybrand Europe. In: Pettigrew, A.M. and Fenton, E.M., (Eds.) The innovating organization, pp. 82-116. London: Sage. Geppert,M., Matten,D. Williams, K. (2003) Challenges for European Management in a Global Context London: Palgrave Macmillan Giddens,A. (1990) The Consequences of Modernity Cambridge: Polity Press. Gluckler, J and Armbruster, T (2003) ‘Bridging Uncertainty in Management Consulting – The Mechanisms of Trust and Networked Reputation’, Organization Studies, 24, 2, 269-297. Hedlund, G. (1986). ‘The Hypermodern MNC—A Heterarchy?’ Human Resource Management, 25: 9–35. —— (1993). ‘Assumptions of Hierarchy and Heterarchy: An Application to the Multinational Corporation’, in S. Ghoshal and D. E. Westney (eds.), Organization Theory and the Multinational Corporation. London: Macmillan. —— (1999). ‘The Intensity and Extensity of Knowledge and the Multinational Corporation as a Nearly Recomposable System’ Management International Review 1999,1, pp.5-44. Henry, O. (2002) The acquisition of symbolic capital by consultants: the French case. In: Kipping, M. and Engwall, L., (Eds.) Management consulting: emergence and dynamics of a knowledge industry, pp. 19-35. Oxford: Oxford University Press Jones, A. (2002) The 'global city' misconceived: the myth of 'global management' in transnational service firms. Geoforum 33, 335-350. Jones, A. (2003) Management Consultancy and Banking in an era of Globalization, edn. London: Palgrave Macmillan. Kipping, M. (2002) Trapped in their Wave: the evolution of management consultancies. In: Clark, T. and Fincham, R., (Eds.) Critical Consulting: New Perspectives on the Management Advice Industry, pp. 28-49. Oxford: Blackwell Kipping, M. and Engwall, L. (2002) Management consulting: emergence and dynamics of a knowledge industry, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Kipping, M., Furusten, S. and Gammelsaeter, H. (2003) Converging towards American dominance? Developments and Structures of Consultancy Fields in Europe. Enterprises et Histoire 33, 25-40. Kristensen, P.H. and Zeitlin, J. (2005) Local Players in Global Games Oxford: Oxford University Press. Lamoreaux, N.R., Raff, D.M.G. and Temin, P. (2002) Beyond Markets and hierarchies: Toward a new synthesis of American Business History. NBER Working Paper Series working paper 9029, Langlois, R.N. (2003) The vanishing hand: the changing dynamics of industrial capitalism. Industrial and Corporate Change 12, 351-385. Lowendahl, B., Revang,O.,Fosstenlokken,S. (2001) Knowledge and Value Creation in professionals Service firms: a framework for analysis Human Relations 54,7,pp.911-931. Lowendahl, B.R. (2000) The globalization of professional business service firms: Fads or genuine source of competitive advantage. In: haroni, Y. and Nachum, L., (Eds.) Globalization of Services, pp. 142-162. London: Routledge McKenna, C., Djelic, M.-L. and Ainamo, A.(2003) ‘Message and medium: the role of consulting firms in globalization and its local interpretation’, in Djelic, M.-L. and Quack, S. (eds.), Globalization and Institutions. Edward Elgar, 83-107. Mills, P K and Morris, M (1986) ‘Clients as Partial Employees of Service Organizations: Role Development in Client Participation’, Academy of Management Review, 11, 4, 726-735 Morgan,G., Whitley,R. and Moen, E. (2005) Changing Capitalisms? Internationalisation, Institutional Change and systems of economic organization Oxford: Oxford University Press. Morgan, G. and Quack,S. (2005) Internationalization and Capability Development in Professional Services Firms in Morgan,G. Whitley,R. and Moen, E. (2005) Changing Capitalisms? Internationalisation, Institutional Change and systems of economic organization pp. 277-311 Oxford: Oxford University Press. Morgan, G. (2005) Understanding Multinational Corporations in Ackroyd,S., Arnold, P., Batt,R. and Thompson,P. The Oxford Handbook of Work and Organizations, pp. 554-576 Oxford: Oxford University Press Morgan, G. and Quack, S. (2004) Institutional legacies and firm dynamics: the internationalization of British and German Law firms’ (Mimeo) Morgan, G. (2001a). Transnational Communities and Business Systems, Global Networks 1(2):113-130 Morgan, G. (2001b).The development of Transnational Standards and Regulations and their Impacts on Firms, in Morgan, G., Kristensen, P.H. and Whitley, R. eds. The Multinational Firm: Organizing Across National and Institutional Divides pp.225-252 Oxford: Oxford University Morgan, G., Kristensen, P.H. and Whitley, R. eds. (2001) The Multinational Firm: Organizing Across National and Institutional Divides Oxford: Oxford University. Nachum, L. (2000) FDI, the location advantages of countries and the competitiveness of TNCs: US FDI in professional service industries. In: Aharoni, Y. and Nachum, L., (Eds.) Globalization of Services, pp. 75-92. London: Routledge Nanda,A. and Morrell,K. (2004) Developing Professionals – The BCG Way (A) Harvard Business School Case 9-903-113 Nohria, N., and Ghoshal, N. (1997). The Differentiated Network: Organizing Multinational Corporations for Value Creation. New York: Jossey-Bass. Pinault, L (2001) Consulting Demons - Inside the Unscrupulous World of Global Corporate Consulting, New York: Harper Business. Roberts, J. (2004) Global management consultancy: conceptual issues concerning the cross-border delivery of knowledge intensive services (paper presented at the British Academy of Management, Sept. 2004) Roberts, J. (1999) The internationalisation of business service firms: a stages approach. Service Industries Journal 19, 68-88. Roberts, J. (1998) The Internationalisation of Business Service Firms, Aldershot: Ashgate. Rose, T. and Hinings, C.R. (1999) Global Clients' demands driving change in global business advisory firms. In: Brock.D., Powell, M. and Hinings, C.R., (Eds.) Restructuring the professional organization, pp. 41-67. London: Routledge. Rudolph, H. and Okech, J. (2003) ‘Computer, Köpfe, Communities of Practice. Internationales Wissensmanagement in großen Unternehmensberatungen’, in Dörrenbächer, C. (ed.) Modelltransfer in Multinationalen Unternehmen. Edition sigma, Berlin, 29-52. Rudolph, H. and Okech, J. (2004) Wer anderen einen Rat erteilt …Wettbewerbsstrategien und Personalpolitiken von Unternehmensberatungen in Deutschland. Edition sigma, Berlin. Sahlin-Andersson, K. and Engwall,L. (2003) The Expansion of Management Knowledge: Carriers, Flows and Sources Stanford: Stanford University Press Sassen,S. (2001) The Global City revised ed. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Solvell, O., and Zander, I. (1998). ‘International Diffusion of Knowledge: Isolating Mechanisms and the Role of the MNE’, in A. D. Chandler, O. Solvell, and P. Hagstrom (eds.), The Dynamic Firm: The Role of Technology, Strategy, Organization and Regions. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Solvell, O. (2003) ‘The Multi-home based Multinational: Combining Global Competitiveness and Local Innovativeness’ in Birkinshaw, J., Ghoshal,S., Markides,C., Stopford,J., Yip,G. (2003) The Future of the Multinational Company pp.34-44 London: Wiley. Spar,D. (1997) Lawyers Abroad: the internationalisation of legal practices California Management Review 39, pp.8-28. Stevens, M (1981) The Big Eight, New York: Collier Sturdy, A. (1997) The consultancy process - an insecure business. Journal of Management Studies 34, 389-413. Sturgeon, T.J. (2002) Modular production networks: a new American model of industrial organization. Industrial and Corporate Change 11, 451-496. Taylor,P.J. (2004) World City Network London: Routledge. Teece, D. (2003) Expert talent and the design of (professional services) firms. Industrial and Corporate Change 12, 895-916. Thrift, N. (1998) Virtual capitalism: the globalisation of reflexive business knowledge. In: Carrier, J.G. and Miller, D., (Eds.) Virtualism: a new political economy, pp. 161-186. Oxford: Berg UNCTAD (2004) World Investment Report 2004 Geneva: UNCTAD. Warf,B. (1997) Global Dimensions of US Legal Services The Professional Geographer, 53,3, pp.398-406. Werr, A. (2002) The internal creation of consulting knowledge: a question of structuring experience. In: Kipping, M. and Engwall, L., (Eds.) Management consulting: emergence and dynamics of a knowledge industry, pp. 91-108. Oxford: Oxford University Press Werr, A. and T.Stjrenberg (2003) Exploring management consulting firms as knowledge systems. Organization Studies 24,6 pp. 881-908. Whitley,R. (2005) Developing Transnational Organizational Capabilities in Multinational Companies: Institutional Constraints on Authority Sharing and Careers in Six Types of MNC in Morgan,G. Whitley,R. and Moen, E. (2005) Changing Capitalisms? Internationalisation, Institutional Change and systems of economic organization pp. 235-276 Oxford: Oxford University Press.|
Actions (login required)