Sullivan, Sian and Homewood, Katherine (2003) On non-equilibrium and nomadism: knowledge, diversity and global modernity in Drylands (and beyond…). Working Paper. University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation, Coventry.

Preview

PDF WRAP_Sullivan_wp12203.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader Download (488Kb)

Abstract

Drylands worldwide, together with the variously nomadic peoples who live there, are associated with the incidence of poverty and environmental degradation. Corresponding assertions of pending social and ecological collapse have paved the way for hegemonic development and policy interventions focusing on the settlement of formerly mobile populations, reductions of livestock numbers, land privatisation and shifts towards commercial and tightly regulated production. Despite the wealth of expertise and monetary resources involved, however, these initiatives have rarely been successful, either in socio-economic or environmental terms. Our aim in this paper is to engage critically with both the conceptual underpinnings and empirical consequences of a globalising modernity as these have played out in dryland environments, and in relation to practices of mobility amongst the peoples who such environments are associated. We draw on a debate that exists in ecology regarding the sources and types of dynamic behaviour driving ecological systems. Drylands have become a particular focus of this debate. In these environments extreme and unpredictable variability in rainfall are considered (by some) to confer non-equilibrium dynamics by continually disrupting the tight consumer-resource relations that would otherwise pull the components of the system towards equilibrium. This implies that livestock grazing in drylands, widely thought to cause degradation and ‘desertification’ through detrimental management practices including mobility and the maximising of herd reproductive rates, in fact might not be causing irreversible ecological change. Or at least not through exceeding a density-dependent equilibrial relationship with forage availability. We attempt to extend discussion by thinking through the cultural and historical contexts leading to a particular ‘shoehorning’ of the dynamics associated with non-equilibrium and nomadism into a conceptual framework that emphasises the desirability of stability, equilibrium and predictability. In doing so, we draw on the explanatory power of theories of conceptual and ritual purification (associated with anthropologist Mary Douglas); of the empowered panopticon society with its requirements for diffuse and minutely controlled surveillance and regulation (cf. Foucault), and of the ideological differences between State and Nomad science as considered by philosophers Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari.

Item Type:	Working or Discussion Paper (Working Paper)
Subjects:	H Social Sciences > HN Social history and conditions. Social problems. Social reform J Political Science > JZ International relations
Divisions:	Faculty of Social Sciences > Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):	Equilibrium (Economics), Globalization -- Social aspects, Nomads, Civilization, Modern, Arid regions
Series Name:	Working papers (University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation)
Publisher:	University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation
Place of Publication:	Coventry
Date:	September 2003
Number:	No.122
Number of Pages:	60
Status:	Not Peer Reviewed
Access rights to Published version:	Open Access
References:	Abramson, A and Theodossopoulos, D. (eds.) (2000) Land, Law and Environment: Mythical Land, Legal Boundaries, Pluto Press, London Adams, W (1992) Wasting the Rain: Rivers, People and Planning in Africa, Earthscan, London Agarwal, B (1999) A Field of One’s Own: Gender and Land Rights in South Asia, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Alexander, J and MacGregor, J (2000) ‘Wildlife and politics: CAMPFIRE in Zimbabwe’, Development and Change, vol 31, pp605-62 Anderson, D (1984) ‘Depression, dust bowl, demography and drought: the colonial state and soil conservation in East Africa during the 1930s’, African Affairs, vol 83, pp321-343 Anderson, D.M and Broch-Due, V (eds.) (1999) The Poor Are Not Us: Poverty and Pastoralism in Eastern Africa, James Currey, East African Educational Publishing, Ohio University Press, Oxford, Nairobi, Ohio Anker, P. (2002) Imperial ecology: environmental order in the British Empire, Massachusetts Harvard University Press, Cambridge Anon (1990-1991) The impact of fuelwood scarcity on dietary patterns: hypotheses for research. Unasylva, vol 41(160), pp29-34 Arab World Geographer (2002) vol 5(2) Attwell, C.A.M and Cotterill, F.P.D (2000) ‘Postmodernism and African conservation science’, Biodiversity and Conservation, vol 9, pp559-577 Aubréville, A (1938) La Forêt Coloniale: Les Forêts de L’Afrique Occidentale Française. Annales d’Academie des Sciences Coloniales IX. Societé d’Editions Géographiques, Maritimes et Coloniales. Barrow, E (1988) ‘Trees and pastoralists: the case of the Pokot and Turkana’, ODI Social Forestry Network Paper 6b, Overseas Development Institute, London Barrow, E (1990) ‘Usufruct rights to trees: the role of Ekwar in dryland central Turkana, Kenya’, Human Ecology, vol 18(2) pp163-176 Baumann, M (2000) ‘On nature, models, and simplicity’, Conservation Ecology, http://www.consecol.org/vol4/iss/2/resp4/ Behnke R (1983) ‘Production Rationales: The Commercialisation of Subsistence Pastoralism’, Nomadic Peoples, vol 14, pp3-34 Behnke, R and Scoones, I (1993) ‘Rethinking Range Ecology: Implications for Rangeland Management in Africa’, pp1-30 in Behnke, R, Scoones, I and Kerven C (eds) Range Ecology at Disequilibrium: New Models of Natural Variability and Pastoral Adaptation in African Savannas, Overseas Development Institute, International Institute of Environment and Development, Commonwealth Secretariat, London Behnke, R.H, Scoones, I and Kerven, C (eds) (1993) Range Ecology at Disequilibrium: New Models of Natural Variability and Pastoral Adaptation in African Savannas, Overseas Development Institute, International Institute of Environment and Development, Commonwealth Secretariat, London Beinart, W (2000) ‘African history and environmental history’, African Affairs, vol 99, pp69-302 Beinart, W (2003) The Rise of Conservation in South Africa: Settlers, Livestock, and the Environment 1770-1950, Oxford University Press, Oxford Belenky, M. F, Clinchy, B.M, Goldberger, N.R and Tarule, J.M (1986) Women's Ways of Knowing: The Development of Self, Voice and Mind, Basic Books, USA Bell, R (1987) ‘Conservation with a Human Face’, pp79-102 in Anderson, D and Grove, R (eds) Conservation in Africa: People, Policies and Practice, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Belsky, A.J (1989) ‘Landscape patterns in a semi-arid ecosystem in East Africa’, Journal of Arid Environments, vol 17, pp265-270 Belsky, A.J (1994) ‘Influences of trees on savanna productivity: tests of shade, nutrients and tree-grass competition’, Ecology, vol 75(4), pp922-932 Belsky, A.J (1995) ‘Spatial and Temporal Patterns in Arid and Semi-Arid African Savannas’, pp31-56 in Hansson, L, Fahrig, L and Merriam, G (eds) Mosaic landscapes and ecological processes, Chapman and Hall, London Belsky, A.J, Amundson, R.G, Riha, S.J, Ali, A.R and Mwonga, S.M (1989) ‘The effect of trees on their physical, chemical and biological environment in a semi-arid savanna (Tsavo) Kenya’, Journal of Applied Ecology, vol 26, pp1005-1024 Belsky, A.J and Canham, C.D (1994) ‘Forest gaps and isolated savanna trees: an application of patch dynamics in two ecosystems’, Bioscience, vol 44(2), pp77-84 Belsky, A.J, Mwonga, S.M, Amundson, R.G, Duxbury, J.M and Ali, A.R (1993a) ‘Comparative effects of isolated trees on their understory environments in high and low rainfall savannas’, Journal of Applied Ecology, vol 30, pp143-155 Belsky, A.J, Mwonga, S.M and Duxbury, J.M (1993b) ‘Effects of widely spaced trees and livestock grazing on the understory environments in tropical savannas’, Agroforestry Systems, vol 24, pp1-20 Bender, B (1998) Stonehenge: Making Space, Berg, Oxford Berkes, F (1989) Common Property Resources: Ecological and Community Based Sustainable Development, Belhaven Press, London Birch, T (1996) ‘“A Land so Inviting and Still Without Inhabitants”’: Erasing Koori Culture From (Post-)colonial Landscapes’, pp173-188 in Darian-Smith, K, Gunner, L and Nuttall, S (eds) Text, Theory and Space: Land, Literature and History in South Africa and Australia, Routledge, London Birley, M.H (1982) ‘Resource management in Sukumaland, Tanzania’, Africa, vol 52(2), pp1-29 Bley, H (1996) Namibia Under German Rule, Germany Lit Verlag, Hamburg Bollig, M (1998a) ‘The colonial encapsulation of the north-western Namibian pastoral economy’, Africa, vol 68(4), pp506-536 Bollig, M (1998b) ‘Power & Trade in Precolonial & Early Colonial Northern Kaokoland 1860s- 1940s’, pp175-193 in Hayes, P, Silvester, J, Wallace, M and Hartmann, W (eds) Namibia Under South Africa Rule: Mobility and Containment 1915-1946, James Currey, Out of Africa, Ohio University, London, Windhoek, Athens Botelle, A and Rohde, R (1995) Those Who Live on the Land: A Socio-economic Baseline Survey for Land Use Planning in the Communal Areas of Eastern Otjozondjupa, Land Use Planning Series, Report 1, Windhoek Bourdieu, P (1977) Outline of a Theory of Practice, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Briske, D.D, Fuhlendorf, S.D and Smeins, F.E (2003) ‘Vegetation dynamics on rangelands: a critique of the current paradigms’, Journal of Applied Ecology, vol 40, pp601-614 Broch-Due, V and Anderson, D.M (1999) ‘Preface’, ppix-xi in Anderson, D.M and Broch-Due, V (eds) The Poor Are Not Us: Poverty and Pastoralism in Eastern Africa, James Currey, East African Educational Publishing, Ohio University Press, Oxford, Nairobi, Ohio Brockington, D (2002) Fortress Conservation: The Preservation of the Mkomazi Game Reserve, Tanzania, James Currey, Oxford Brockington, D and Homewood, K (1996) ‘Wildlife, Pastoralists and Science: Debates Concerning Mkomazi Game Reserve, Tanzania’, pp91-104 in Leach, M and Mearns, R (eds) The Lie of the Land: Challenging Received Wisdom on the African Environment, The International African Institute, James Currey, Heinemann, London, Oxford and Portsmouth Brockington, D and Homewood, K (1998) ‘Pastoralism Around Mkomazi Game Reserve: The Interaction of Conservation and Development’, pp? in Coe, M, McWilliam, N, Stone, G and Packer, M (eds) Mkomazi: The Ecology, Biodiversity and Conservation of a Tanzanian Savanna, RoyalGeographical Society (with the Institute of British Geographers), London Brockington, D and Homewood, K (2001) ‘Degradation debates and data deficiencies. The case of the Mkomazi Game Reserve, Tanzania’, Africa, vol 71, pp179-227 Bromley, D and Cernea, W (1989) The Management of Common Property Resources: Some Conceptual and Operational Fallacies, World Bank, Washington Brown, D (1970) Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee: An Indian History of the American West, Vintage, London Campbell, K and Borner, M (1995) ‘Population Trends and Distribution of Serengeti Herbivores: Implications for Management’, pp117-145, in Sinclair, A.R.E and Arcese, P (eds) Serengeti II. Dynamics, Management and Conservation of an Ecosystem, University of Chicago Press, Chicago Campbell, K and Hofer, H (1995) ‘People and Wildlife: Spatial Dynamics and Zones of Interaction’, pp534-570 in Sinclair, A.R.E and Arcese, P (eds) Serengeti II. Dynamics, Management and Conservation of an Ecosystem, University of Chicago Press, Chicago Campbell, B.M, Costanza, R and van den Belt, M (2000) ‘Special section: land use options in dry tropical woodland ecosystems in Zimbabwe: introduction, overview and synthesis’, Ecological Economics, vol 33 pp341-351 Caro, T (1999a) ‘Densities of mammals in partially protected areas: the Katavi ecosystem of western Tanzania’, Journal of Applied Ecology, vol 36, pp205-217 Caro, T (1999b) ‘Demography and behaviour of African mammals subject to exploitation’, Biological Conservation, vol 91, pp91-97 Carswell, G (2002) ‘Farmers and fallowing: agricultural change in Kigezi District, Uganda’, The Geographical Journal, vol 168(2), pp130-140 Carter, A.J and O'Connor, T.G (1990) ‘A Two-Phase Mosaic in a Savanna Grassland’, Journal of Vegetation Science, vol2, pp231-236 Caughley, G, Shepherd, N and Short, J (eds) (1987) Kangaroos: Their Ecology and Management in the Sheep Rangelands of Australia, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Charney, J, Stone, P and Quirk, W (1975) ‘Drought in the Sahara: a biogeophysical feedback mechanism’, Science, vol 187, pp434-435 Chatty, D (2003) ‘Environmentalism in the Syrian Badia: the Assumptions of Degradation, Protection and Bedouin Misuse’, pp 87-99 in Anderson, D.G and Berglund, E. (eds) Ethnographies of Conservation: Environmentalism and the Distribution of Privilege, Berghahn Books, Oxford Chatwin, B (1987) The Songlines, Picador, London Cilliers, P (1998) Complexity and Postmodernism: Understanding Complex Systems, Routledge, London Clements, F.E (1916) Plant Succession: an Analysis of the Development of Vegetation, Carnegie Institute Publications 242, Washington Clynes, T (2002) ‘They shoot poachers, don’t they?’ The Observer 24 November 2002, OM Dispatches pp35-47 Corbett, M. (in press) ‘Sound organisation: a brief history of psychosonic management’, ephemera: critical dialogues on organization, vol 3(4) Corbin, A (1996 (1982)) The Foul and the Fragrant: Odour and the Social Imagination, Papermac, London Cossins, N and Upton, M (1987) ‘The Borana pastoral system of Southern Ethiopia’, Agricultural Systems, vol 25, pp199-218 Coughenour, M.B, Coppock, D.L and Ellis, J.E (1990) ‘Herbaceous forage variability in an arid pastoral region of Kenya: importance of topographic and rainfall gradients’, Journal of Arid Environments vol 19, pp147-159 Coughenour, M.B, Ellis, J.E, Swift, D.M, Coppock, D.L, Galvin, K, McCabe, J.T and Hart, T.C (1985) ‘Energy extraction and use in a nomadic pastoral ecosystem’, Science, vol 230, pp619-624 Cowling, R (2000) ‘Challenges to the ‘new’ rangeland science’, Trends in Ecology and Evolution (TREE), vol 15, pp303-304 Cross, M (1985) ‘Waiting for a green revolution’, New Scientist, vol 105, pp36-40 Dahl, G. (1987) ‘Women in pastoral production: some theoretical notes on roles and resources’, Ethnos, vol 52(1-2), pp246-279 Davies J, Higginbottom, K, Noack, D, Ross, H and Young, E (1999) ‘Sustaining Eden: indigenous community wildlife management in Australia’, Evaluating Eden Series No.1, International Institute of Environment and Development, London Davis S, Heywood, V and Hamilton, A (eds) (1994) Centres of Plant Diversity, WWF/IUCN, Gland, Switzerland Debaine, F and Jaubert, R (2002) ‘The degradation of the steppe, hypotheses and realities’, The Arab World Geographer 5 (2) 124-140 De Certeau, M. (1984) The Practice of Everyday Life, University of California Press, Berkeley Deleuze, G and Guattari, F (1988 (1980)) A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia (translation and foreword by Brain Massumi), The Athlone Press, London Dennis, C (2003) ‘Burning issues’, Nature vol 421, pp204-206 De Rosnay, J (1979 (1975)) The Macroscope: A New World Scientific System (Translated by Robert Edwards), Harper and Row, New York Dirk Moses, A (2000) ‘An antipodean genocide? The origins of the genocidal moment in the colonization of Australia’, Journal of Genocide Research, vol 2(1), pp89-106 Douglas, M (1966) Purity and Danger, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London Dublin, H.T (1991) ‘Dynamics of the Serengeti-Mara woodlands: an historic perspective’, Forest and Conservation History, vol 35, pp169-178 Dublin, H.T, Sinclair, A.R.E and McGlade, J (1990) ‘Elephants and fire as causes of multiple states in the Serengeti-Mara woodlands’, Journal of Animal Ecology vol 59, pp1147-1164 Dublin, H (1995) ‘Vegetation Dynamics in the Serengeti-Mara Ecosystem: The Role of Elephants, Fire and Other Factors’, pp71-90 in Sinclair, A.R.E and Arcese, P (eds) Serengeti II. Dynamics, Management and Conservation of an Ecosystem, University of Chicago Press, Chicago Duffy, R (2000) Killing for Conservation: Wildlife Policy in Zimbabwe, The International African Institute, James Currey, Indiana University Press and Weaver, London, Oxford, Indianapolis and Harare Ellis, J. E (1994) ‘Climate Variability and Complex Ecosystem Dynamics: Implications for Pastoral Development’, pp37-46 in Scoones, I (ed) Living With Uncertainty, Intermediate Technology Publications, London Ellis, J.E, Coughenour, M.B and Swift, D.M (1993) ‘Climate variability, ecosystem stability, and the implications for range and livestock development’, pp31-41 in Behnke, R.H, Scoones, I and Kerven, C (eds) Range Ecology at Disequilibrium: New Models of Natural Variability and Pastoral Adaptation in African Savannas, Overseas Development Institute, International Institute of Environment and Development, Commonwealth Secretariat, London Ellis, J.E and Swift, D.M (1988) ‘Stability of African pastoral ecosystems: alternative paradigms and implications for development’, Journal of Range Management, vol 41, pp450-459 Escobar, A (1996) Encountering Development, Princeton University Press, Princeton Fairhead, J (2000) Book review article of Richards, P.W (1996) The Tropical Rain Forest(2nd edition), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge’, Progress in Physical Geography, vol 24, pp609-613 Foucault, M (1981) Power/knowledge: selected interviews and other writings, 1972-1977 (edited by Gordon, C) Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead Fraser, S (2003) Parks, Pastoralists & Development Policy In The Nigerian Savanna: A Situated Study of the Politics of Land and Land-Use Reform in Relation to Migratory Pastoralists, Ph.D. Thesis, University of London Fuller, Ben B. Jnr (1993) Institutional Appropriation and Social Change Among Agropastoralists in Central Namibia 1916-1988, Ph.D. Dissertation, Boston Graduate School, Boston Galaty, J.G (1999) Double-voiced Violence in Kenya, Paper presented at the Workshop on ‘Conflict's fruit: poverty, violence and the politics of identity in African arenas,’ 21-24 October 1999, Sophienburg Castle, Denmark Galaty, J.G and Bonte, P (1992) Herders, Warriors and Traders: Pastoralism in Africa, Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado Gadgil, M (1993) ‘Restoring the Productivity of Indian Savannas’, pp221-238 in Young, M.D and Solbrig, O (eds) The World’s Savannas: Economic Driving Forces, Ecological Constraints and Policy Options for Sustainable Land Use, Vol 12, Man and Biosphere Series, UNESCO and Parthenon Publishing Group, Carnforth and New York Gordon, R.J (1972) ‘Towards an ethnography of Bergdama gossip’, Namib und Meer, vol 2, pp45-47 Gordon, R.J (1991) ‘Vernacular law and the future of human rights in Namibia’, NISER Discussion Paper 11, Namibian Institute for Socio-economic Research, Windhoek, Namibia Gordon, R.J (1998) ‘Vagrancy, Law and ‘Shadow Knowledge’: Internal Pacification 1915-1939’, pp 51-75 in Hayes, P, Silvester, J, Wallace, M and Hartmann, W (eds) Namibia Under South African Rule: Mobility and Containment 1915-1946, James Currey, Out of Africa Publishers and Ohio University Oxford, Windhoek, Ohio Gordon, R.J and Sholto Douglas, S (2000) The Bushman Myth: The Making of a Namibian Underclass (2nd edition), Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado Government of Tanzania (1997) ‘Livestock and Agriculture Policy’, pp 55-68 Section 3 Soil conservation and Land use planning, and Section 4: Range Management pp127-131 Policy statements. Dar es Salaam, Tanzania Graham, O (1988) ‘Enclosure of the East African rangelands: recent
URI:	http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/id/eprint/1999

Request changes to a record

Actions (login required)

View Item