The Library

Defending biomedical authority and regulating the womb as social space. Prenatal testing in the Polish press

Tools

Kramer, Anne-Marie Caroline. (2010) Defending biomedical authority and regulating the womb as social space. Prenatal testing in the Polish press. European Journal of Women's Studies, Vol.17 (No.1). pp. 43-59. ISSN 1350-5068

PDF
WRAP_Kramer_0370213-so-190310-most_recently_revised_kramer.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
Download (521Kb)

Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1350506809350860

Abstract

The issue of abortion has been the topic of heated and frequent debate in post-Communist Poland. Parliamentary debate in 1998—9 centred around a legislative attempt to restrict prenatal testing, specifically amniocentesis, in order to further reduce the numbers of abortions carried out, as it was argued to inevitably result in the termination of pregnancy. Medical professionals are rarely visible as subjects of and authorities on the abortion debate in the Polish context. However, in this debate around prenatal testing, the medical community appear as key commentators and meaning-makers. This article asks the following questions: What role do the medical profession and biomedical knowledge play in the debate around prenatal testing, when abortion is highly politicized? Second, what social meanings and consequences are attributed to prenatal testing? How do these construct the relationship between foetus, pregnant woman and doctor, and what agency and 'rights' are attributed to women in the process of prenatal testing?

Item Type:

Journal Article

Subjects:

H Social Sciences > HQ The family. Marriage. Woman
R Medicine > RG Gynecology and obstetrics

Divisions:

Faculty of Social Sciences > Sociology

Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):

Human reproduction -- Political aspects -- Poland, Prenatal diagnosis -- Poland, Amniocentesis -- Poland, Abortion -- Law and legislation -- Poland, Prenatal diagnosis -- Social aspects

Journal or Publication Title:

European Journal of Women's Studies

Publisher:

Sage Publications Ltd.

ISSN:

1350-5068

Official Date:

February 2010

Dates:

Date	Event
February 2010	Published

Volume:

Vol.17

Number:

No.1

Page Range:

pp. 43-59

Identification Number:

10.1177/1350506809350860

Status:

Peer Reviewed

Access rights to Published version:

Restricted or Subscription Access

References:

Bodnar, Adam (2008) ‘Analysis of court cases concerning the lack of availability of
services for terminating pregnancy in Poland’ in Nowicka (ed.) Reproductive Rights in Poland: The effects of the anti-abortion law. Available at http://www.federa.org.pl/publikacje/report%20Federa_eng_NET.PDF Accessed April 2009.
Boratyn, Iwona (02-03/6/1999) ‘At the end of the needle’, Gazeta Wyborcza.
Bordo, Susan (1993) Unbearable weight: Feminism, western culture and the
body. Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press.
Borkowska, Grażyna (22-23/5/1999) ‘In respect for the law. Controversy
regarding pre-natal tests’, Gazeta Wyborcza.
Czech, Robert (15/10/1999) ‘Interview with Dr Sławomir Redżko: Safe body’, Gazeta
Wyborcza.
Cichocka, Elżbieta (10-11/07/1999) ‘The barrier of ignorance’, Wysokie
obcasy supplement, Gazeta Wyborcza.
Domaradzka, Anna (2008) ‘Report of the expert research with gynaecologists and
midwives’ in Nowicka (ed.) Reproductive Rights in Poland: The effects of the anti-abortion law. Available at: http://www.federa.org.pl/publikacje/report%20Federa_eng_NET.PDF
Accessed April 2009.
Draper, Jan (2002) ‘“It was a real good show”: the ultrasound scan, fathers and the power of visual knowledge’, Sociology of Health and Illness 24(6): 771-795.
Ettorre, Elizabeth (2002) Reproductive genetics, gender and the body London & New York: Routledge
Farquhar, Dion (1996) The other machine: Discourse and reproductive technologies. London & New York: Routledge.
Gal, Susan & Kligman, Gail (2000) The Politics of Gender after Socialism.
Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Gazeta Wyborcza (22-23/5/1999a) ‘Theme of the day: Pre-natal tests’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (22–23/5/1999b) ‘Public opinion’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (24/5/1999) ‘The country in brief’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (26/5/1999) ‘Ideology of the uterus’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (27/5/1999) ‘The country in brief’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (04/6/1999) ‘About tests’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (11/6/1999) ‘Senate Committee on pre-natal tests. Limitations are
not necessary’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (18/06/1999) ‘In the Senate on pre-natal tests. Conditions
and traps’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (19-20/6/1999) ‘Pre-natal tests. The Senate puts Away’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (22/06/1999a) ‘They rejected the amendments because
they think about the law. Behind the scenes of the Senate decision on the matter of pre-natal tests.’
Gazeta Wyborcza (22/06/1999b) ‘Pre-natal ping pong’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (09/7/1999a) ‘CBOS on pre-natal tests. Everybody should
have this right’.
Gazeta Wyborcza (09/7/1999b) ‘The Sejm has decided. Pre-natal tests – yes’.
Ghai, Anita & Johri, Rachana (2008) ‘Prenatal diagnosis: Where do we draw the
line?’ Indian Journal of Gender Studies 15(2): 291-316
Kozerawska, Małgorzata (23/02/1999) ‘Geneticists wait for patients. Spying on
chromosomes’, Gazeta Wyborcza.
Kulczycki, Andrzej (1995) 'Abortion policy in postcommunist Europe: The conflict in
Poland', Population and Development Review 21(3): 471-505.
Martens, Krzysztof (05-06/6/1999) ‘The alphabet of Krzysztof Marten. On the
stiffness of thinking’, Gazeta Wyborcza.
Martens, Krzysztof (17-18/9/1999) ‘The alphabet of Krzysztof Marten. The various
colours of hypocrisy’, Gazeta Wyborcza.
McLaughlin, Janice (2003) ‘Screening networks: Shared agendas in feminist and
disability movement challenges to antenatal screening and abortion’ Disability & Society 18(3): 297-310
Mossakowski, Mirosław (02-03/6/1999) ‘Pre-natal testing is not an experiment’,
Gazeta Wyborcza.
Millard, Frances (1995) 'Women in Poland: the impact of post-communist
transformation 1989-1994', Journal of Area Studies 6: Special Issue ‘Women in Eastern and Western Europe - in Transition and Recession’: 60-73.
Mitchell, Lisa M. (2001) Baby’s first picture: Ultrasound and the politics of fetal
subjects Toronto & London: University of Toronto Press
Nowicka, Wanda (1997) Poland: Case study on legal instability concerning
abortion. Preventing and addressing unsafe abortion: a technical consultation, 8-11 December 1997 WHO, Geneva .
Available at http://www.federa.org.pl?English/public/whoabor.htm
Accessed: April 2009.
Nowicka, Wanda (2000) Ethical Considerations on Anti-Abortion Law, Poland: Safe
Abortion: A WHO Technical Consultation, To develop technical and policy guidance for healthy systems, 18-22 September 2000, Geneva.
Available at http://home.nextra.sk/sspprv/nowicka.htm
Accessed: April 2006.
Nowicka, Wanda (2008) ‘The Anti-abortion Act in Poland – the legal and actual state’
in Nowicka (ed.) Reproductive Rights in Poland: The effects of the anti-abortion law. Available at
http://www.federa.org.pl/publikacje/report%20Federa_eng_NET.PDF Accessed April 2009.
Parens, Eric & Asch, Adrienne (eds.) Prenatal testing and disability rights
Washington: Georgetown University Press
Rapp, Rayna (1999) Testing women, testing the foetus: The social impact of
amniocentesis in America. London & New York: Routledge.
Rothman, Barbara (1996) The tentative pregnancy: Pre-natal diagnosis and the future
of motherhood. London: Pandora.
Santalahti, Päivi, Konstantinos, Petrogiannis & Tymstra, Tjeerd (2001) ‘Women’s
decision-making and experiences of prenatal Down’s syndrome screening’ in Ettorre (ed.) Before birth: Understanding prenatal screening Aldershot: Ashgate
Shakespeare, Tom (2006) Disability rights and wrongs London & New York:
Routledge
Sharp, Keith & Earle, Sarah (2002) 'Feminism, Disability and Abortion:
Irreconcilable Differences?' Disability & Society 17(2): 137-45.
Titkow, Anna (1994) 'Polish women in politics: an introduction to the status of
women in Poland', pp.29-34 in Rueschmeyer, M. (ed.) Women in the Politics of Postcommunist Eastern Europe. New York and London: ME Sharpe.
Zielińska, Eleonora (2000) ‘Between Ideology, Politics, and Common Sense: The
Discourse of Reproductive Rights in Poland’, pp.23-57 in Gal, S& Kligman, G. (eds.) Reproducing Gender: Politics, Publics, and Everyday Life after Socialism Princeton: Princeton University Press.