Bhambra, Gurminder K.. (2010) Historical sociology, international relations and connected histories. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, Vol.23 (No.1). pp. 127-143. ISSN 0955-7571

PDF WRAP_Bhambra_Bhambra_CRIA_Dec_2009.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader Download (356Kb)

Abstract

This article addresses three recent developments in historical sociology: (1) neo-Weberian historical sociology within International Relations; (2) the 'civilizational analysis' approach utilized by scholars of 'multiple modernities'; and (3) the 'third wave' cultural turn in US historical sociology. These developments are responses to problems identified within earlier forms of historical sociology, but it is suggested each fails to resolve them precisely because each remains contained within the methodological framework of historical sociology as initially conceived. It is argued that their common problem lies in the utilization of 'ideal types' as the basis for sociohistorical analysis. This necessarily has the effect of abstracting a set of particular relations from their wider connections and has the further effect of suggesting sui generis endogenous processes as integral to these relations. In this way, each of the three developments continues the Eurocentrism typical of earlier approaches. The article concludes with a call for 'connected histories' to provide a more adequate methodological and substantive basis for an historical sociology appropriate to calls for a properly global historical sociology.

Item Type:	Journal Article
Subjects:	H Social Sciences > HM Sociology
Divisions:	Faculty of Social Sciences > Sociology
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):	Sociology -- History, International relations -- Sociological aspects, Sociology -- Methodology, Civilization, Modern -- Philosophy
Journal or Publication Title:	Cambridge Review of International Affairs
Publisher:	Routledge
ISSN:	0955-7571
Date:	March 2010
Volume:	Vol.23
Number:	No.1
Page Range:	pp. 127-143
Identification Number:	10.1080/09557570903433639
Status:	Peer Reviewed
Access rights to Published version:	Restricted or Subscription Access
References:	Abbott, Andrew (1991) „History and sociology: the lost synthesis‟, Social Science History, 15:2, 20138 Abrams, Philip (1980) „History, sociology, historical sociology‟, Past and Present, 87, 316 Adams, Julia, Elisabeth S Clemens and Ann Shola Orloff (eds) (2005a) Remaking modernity: politics, history and sociology (Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press) Adams, Julia, Elisabeth S Clemens and Ann Shola Orloff (2005b) „Introduction: social theory, modernity and the three waves of historical sociology‟ in Julia Adams, Elisabeth S Clemens and Ann Shola Orloff (eds) Remaking modernity: politics, history and sociology (Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press), 172 Althusser, Louis (1969) For Marx (London: Allen Lane) Arnason, Johann (2000) „Communism and modernity‟, Daedalus: Multiple Modernities, 129:1, 6190 Arnold, David (1984) „Gramsci and peasant subalternity in India‟, The Journal of Peasant Studies, 11:4, 15577 Barkawi, Tarak (2004) „Connection and constitution: locating war and culture in Globalization Studies‟, Globalizations, 1:2, 15570 Barkawi, Tarak and Mark Laffey (2006) „The postcolonial moment in Security Studies‟, Review of International Studies, 32:4, 32952 Bhambra, Gurminder K (2007a) Rethinking modernity: postcolonialism and the sociological imagination (Basingstoke: Palgrave) Bhambra, Gurminder K (2007b) „Sociology and postcolonialism: another “missing” revolution?‟ Sociology, 41:5, 87184 Bonnell, Victoria (1980) „The uses of theory, concepts and comparison in historical sociology‟, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 22:2, 15673 Bonnell, Victoria E and Lynn Hunt (eds) (1999a) Beyond the cultural turn: new directions in the study of society and culture (Berkeley: University of California Press) Bonnell, Victoria E and Lynn Hunt (1999b) „Introduction‟ in Victoria E Bonnell and Lynn Hunt (eds) Beyond the cultural turn: new directions in the study of society and culture (Berkeley: University of California Press), 132 Brenner, Robert (1976) „Agrarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe‟, Past and Present, 70, 3075 Brenner, Robert (1977) „The origins of capitalist development: a critique of neo-Smithian Marxism‟, New Left Review, I:104, 2592 Buzan, Barry and Richard Little (2001) International systems in world history (Oxford: University of Oxford Press) Buzan, Barry and Richard Little (2002) „International systems in world history: remaking the study of IR‟ in Stephen Hobden and John M Hobson (eds) Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 200220 Chaturvedi, Vinayak (ed) (2000) Mapping Subaltern Studies and the postcolonial (London: Verso) Daedalus (1998) Special issue on ‘Early Modernities’, 127:3 Daedalus (2000) Special issue on ‘Multiple Modernities’, 129:1 Dirlik, Arif (2003) „Global modernity? Modernity in an age of global capitalism‟, European Journal of Social Theory, 6:3, 27592 Eisenstadt, Shmuel N (1965) „Transformation of social, political, and cultural orders in modernization‟, American Sociological Review, 30:5, 65973 Eisenstadt, Shmuel N (2000a) „Multiple Modernities‟, Daedalus, 129:1, 129 Eisenstadt, Shmuel N (2000b) „The civilisational dimension in sociological analysis‟, Thesis Eleven, 62,, 121 Eisenstadt, Shmuel N (2001) „The civilisational dimension of modernity: modernity as a distinct civilisation‟, International Sociology, 16:3, 32040 Eisenstadt, Shmuel N and Wolfgang Schluchter (1998) „Introduction: paths to early modernitiesa comparative view‟, Daedalus, 127:3, 118 Giddens, Anthony (1981) A contemporary critique of historical materialism, volume 1: power, property and the state (London: Macmillan) Guha, Ranajit (ed) (1982) Subaltern studies I: writings on South Asian history and society (Delhi: Oxford University Press) Guha, Ranajit (ed) (1983) Subaltern studies II: writings on South Asian history and society (Delhi: Oxford University Press) Hall, Martin and Patrick Jackson (eds) (2007) Civilizational identity: the production and reproduction of ‘civilizations’ in International Relations (Basingstoke: Palgrave) Hobden, Stephen (1998) International Relations and historical sociology (New York: Routledge) Hobden, Stephen (2002) „Historical sociology: back to the future of International Relations‟ in Stephen Hobden and John M Hobson (eds) Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 42-61 Hobden, Stephen and John M Hobson (eds) (2002) Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) Hobsbawm, E J (1971) „From Social History to the History of Society‟, Daedalus 100, 26, 2045 Hobson, John M (2002) „The two waves of Weberian historical sociology in International Relations‟ in S Hobden and J M Hobson (eds) Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 63-81 Hobson, John M (2004) The eastern origins of western civilization (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) Hobson, John M (2007a) „Reconstructing IR through world history: oriental globalization and the global-dialogic conception of inter-civilizational relations‟, International Politics, 44: 4, 41430 Hobson, John M (2007b) „Is critical theory always for the white west and for western imperialism? Beyond Westphilian, towards a post-racist critical IR‟, Review of International Studies, 33, 91116 Hobson, John M and Stephen Hobden (2002) „On the road towards an historicised world sociology‟ in Stephen Hobden and John M Hobson (eds), Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 265-85 Hobson, John M and George Lawson (2008) „What is history in International Relations?‟ Millennium, 27: 2, 41535 Holmwood, John (1996) Founding Sociology? Talcott Parsons and the idea of general theory (Harlow: Longman Group Ltd) Holmwood, John (2001) „Gender and critical realism: a critique of Sayer‟, Sociology, 35:4, 94765 International Sociology (2001) Special Issue on ‘Rethinking Civilizational Analysis’, 16: 3 Jacob, Margaret C (1999) „Science studies after social construction: the turn toward the comparative and the global‟ in Victoria E Bonnell and Lynn Hunt (eds) Beyond the cultural turn: new directions in the study of society and culture (Berkeley: University of California Press), 95120. Jaspers, Karl (1965) The Origin And Goal Of History (New Haven: Yale University Press) Kalberg, Stephen (1994) Max Weber’s comparative-historical sociology (Cambridge: Polity Press) Landes, David S (1999) The wealth and poverty of nations: why some are so rich and some so poor (London: Abacus) Lawson, George (2007) „Historical sociology in International Relations: open society, research programme and vocation‟, International Politics, 44: 4, 34369 Linklater, Andrew (2002) „Towards a critical historical sociology of transnational harm‟ in Stephen Hobden and John M Hobson (eds) Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 162-80 Mann, Michael (2006) „Explaining International Relations, empires and European miracles: a response‟, Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 34: 2, 54150 Matin, Kamran (2007) „Uneven and combined development in world history: the international relations of state-formation in premodern Iran‟, European Journal of International Relations, 13: 3, 41947 Moore, Barrington Jr. (1966) Social origins of dictatorship and democracy: lord and peasant in the making of the modern world (Boston: Beacon Press) Nelson, Lynn Hankinson (1993) „Epistemological communities‟ in Linda Alcoff and Elizabeth Potter (eds) Feminist epistemologies (London: Routledge), 12160 Parsons, Talcott (1971) The system of modern societies (New Jersey: Prentice-Hall Inc) Reus-Smit, Christian (2002) „The idea of history and history with ideas‟ in Stephen Hobden and John M Hobson (eds) Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 120-40 Rosenberg, Justin (2006) „Why is there no international historical sociology?‟ European Journal of International Relations, 12: 3, 30740 Rosenberg, Justin (2007) „International Relationsthe “higher” bullshit‟: a reply to the globalisation theory debate‟, International Politics, 44: 4, 45082 Sarkar, Sumit (1985) „Social history: predicaments and possibilities‟, Economic and Political Weekly, 20:25/26, 10818 Shaw, Martin (2002) „Globality and historical sociology: state, revolution and war revisited‟ in Stephen Hobden and John M Hobson (eds) Historical sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 82-98 Skocpol, Theda (ed) (1984a) Vision and method in historical sociology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) Skocpol, Theda (1984b) „Emerging agendas and recurrent strategies in historical sociology‟ in Theda Skocpol (ed) Vision and method in historical sociology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 356-91 Skocpol, Theda (1987) „Social history and historical sociology: contrasts and complementarities‟, Social Science History, 11:1, 1730 Skocpol, Theda and Margaret Somers (1980) „The uses of comparative history in macrosocial inquiry‟, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 22: 2, 17497 Smith, Steve (2002) „Historical sociology and International Relations theory‟ in Stephen Hobden and John M Hobson (eds) Historical Sociology of International Relations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 223-43 Stedman-Jones, G (1976) „From Historical Sociology to theoretical history‟, British Journal of Sociology, 27, 295305 Subrahmanyam, Sanjay (1997) „Connected histories: notes towards a reconfiguration of early modern Eurasia‟, Modern Asian Studies, 31:3, 73562 Teschke, Benno (2005) „Bourgeois revolution, state-formation and the absence of the international‟, Historical Materialism: Research in Critical Marxist Theory, 13: 2, 326 Therborn, Goran (2003) „Entangled modernities‟, European Journal of Social Theory, 6:3, 293305 Tilly, Charles (1985a) Big structures, large processes, huge comparisons (New York: Russell Sage Foundation) Tilly, Charles (1985b) „Retrieving European lives‟ in Olivier Zunz (ed) Reliving the past: the worlds of social history (Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press), 1152 Tilly, Charles (1988) „Future history‟, Theory and Society, 17:5, 70312 Wagner, Peter (2008) Modernity as experience and interpretation: a new sociology of modernity (Cambridge: Polity Press) Wallerstein, Immanuel (1974) The modern world-system I: capitalist agriculture and the origins of the European world-economy in the sixteenth century (New York: Academic Press) Wallerstein, Immanuel (1979) The capitalist world-economy: essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) Wallerstein, Immanuel (1980) The modern world-system II: mercantilism and the consolidation of the European world-economy, 16001750 (New York: Academic Press) Wallerstein, Immanuel (2000) „From sociology to historical social science: prospects and obstacles‟, The British Journal of Sociology, 51:1, 2535 Washbrook, David A (1997) „From comparative sociology to global history: Britain and India in the pre-history of modernity‟, Journal of Economic and Social History of the Orient, 40: 4, 41043 Wittrock, Bjorn (1998) „Early modernities: varieties and transitions‟, Daedalus, 27:3, 1940 Wood, Ellen Meiksins (2002) The origin of capitalism: a longer view (London: Verso) Zunz, Olivier (ed) (1985) Reliving the past: the worlds of social history (Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press)
URI:	http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/id/eprint/3389

Request changes to a record

Actions (login required)

View Item