Opting for opting in? : an evaluation of the European Commission’s proposals for reforming VAT on financial services
La Feria, Rita de and Lockwood, Ben (2010) Opting for opting in? : an evaluation of the European Commission’s proposals for reforming VAT on financial services. Working Paper. Coventry: University of Warwick. Dept. of Economics. (Warwick economics research paper series (TWERPS)).
WRAP_Feria_twerp_927.pdf - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
Official URL: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/resear...
This paper provides a legal and economic analysis of the European Commission’s recent proposals for reforming the application of VAT to financial services, with particular focus on their “third pillar”, under which firms would be allowed to opt-into taxation on exempt insurance and financial services. From a legal perspective, we show that the proposals’ “first and second pillar” would give rise to considerable interpretative and qualification problems, resulting in as much complexity and legal uncertainty as the current regime. Equally, an option to tax could potentially follow significantly different legal designs, which would give rise to discrepancies in the application of the option amongst Member States. On the economic side, we show that quite generally, when firms cannot coordinate their behaviour, they have an individual incentive to opt-in on business-to-business (B2B) transactions, but not on business-to-consumer (B2C) transactions. We also show that opting in eliminates the cost disadvantage that EU financial services firms face in competing with foreign firms for B2B sales. But, these results do not hold if firms can coordinate their behaviour. An estimate of the upper bound on the amount of tax revenue that might be lost from allowing opting-in is provided for a number of EU countries.
|Item Type:||Working or Discussion Paper (Working Paper)|
|Subjects:||H Social Sciences > HG Finance
H Social Sciences > HJ Public Finance
|Divisions:||Faculty of Social Sciences > Economics|
|Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):||Value-added tax -- Law and legislation -- European Union countries, Financial services industry -- Taxation, Financial services industry -- Law and legislation, European Commission|
|Series Name:||Warwick economics research paper series (TWERPS)|
|Publisher:||University of Warwick. Dept. of Economics|
|Place of Publication:||Coventry|
|Status:||Not Peer Reviewed|
|Access rights to Published version:||Open Access|
|Funder:||Economic and Social Research Council (Great Britain) (ESRC), European Tax Policy Forum (ETPF)|
|Grant number:||RES-060-25-0033 (ESRC)|
|References:||Anderson,A. , A. de Palma, and B.Kreider (2001), “Tax Incidence in Differentiated Product Oligopoly”, Journal of Public Economics 81, 173-192 Auerbach, A. J. and R.H. Gordon (2002), “Taxation of Financial Services under a VAT” The American Economic Review 92, 411-416 Barham, V., S.N. Poddar and J. Whalley (1987), “The Tax Treatment of Insurance Under a Consumption Type, Destination Basis VAT” National Tax Journal 40, 171-182 Borselli, F. (2009), “A Sensible Reform of the EU VAT Regime for Financial Services” International VAT Monitor 5, 375-383 Commission of the European Communities (2008), Proposals on VAT Treatment of Insurance and Financial Services: Case Studies Commission of the European Communities (2007c), Impact Assessment Summary – Commission Staff Working Paper accompanying the Proposal for a Directive amending Directive 2006/112/EC on the common system of value added tax, as regards the treatment of insurance and financial services, SEC(2007) 1555, 28 November 2007 Commission of the European Communities (2007b), Proposal for a Council Directive amending Directive 2006/112/EC on the common system of value added tax, as regards the treatment of insurance and financial services, COM(2007) 747 final, 28 November 2007 Commission of the European Communities (2007a), Proposal for a Council Regulation laying down implementing measures for Directive 2006/112/EC on the common system of value added tax, as regards the treatment of insurance and financial services, COM(2007) 746 final, 28 November 2007 Commission of the European Communities (2006), Consultation Paper on Modernising Value Added Tax Obligations for Financial Services and Insurances Commission of the European Communities (2000), The TCA System – A Detailed Description Cnossen, S. (1999), “VAT Treatment of Financial Services” in G. Lindenorwa, S.O. Lodin and B. Wiman (eds.), International Studies in Taxation: Law and Economics (The Hague: Kluwer Law International, Series on International Taxation No. 21), 92-104 de la Feria, R. (2007), “The EU VAT treatment of insurance and financial services (again) under review” EC Tax Review 2, 74-89 de la Feria, R. and M. Walpole (2009), “Options for Taxing Financial Supplies in Value Added Tax: EU VAT and Australian GST Models Compared” International and Comparative Law Quarterly 58(4), 897-932 Ebrill, L., M. Keen, J-P. Bodin, and V. Summers (2001), The Modern VAT (Washington D.C.: International Monetary Fund) Edgar, T. (2001), “Exempt Treatment of Financial Services Under Value-Added Tax: An Assessment of Alternatives” Canadian Tax Journal 49(5), 1133-1219 Ernst & Young (2009), Design and Impact of the ‘Option to Tax’ System for Application of VAT to Financial Services, Report prepared fro the European Banking Federation Grambeck, H.M. (2009), “Outsourcing in the EU Financial Sector – Where Are We Heading?” International VAT Monitor 6, 462-473 Grubert, H. and J. Mackie (2000), “Must Financial Services Be Taxed Under a Consumption Tax?” National Tax Journal 53, 23-40 Henkow, O. (2008), Financial Activities in European VAT – A Theoretical and Legal Research of the European VAT System and the Actual and Preferred Treatment of Financial Activities (Austin / Boston / Chicago / New York / The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International, Eucotax Series on European Taxation) HM Treasury (2007), Tax Ready Reckoner and Tax Reliefs Hoffman, L.A., S.N. Poddar and J. Whalley (1987), “Taxation of Banking Services Under a Consumption Type, Destination Basis VAT” National Tax Journal 40, 547-554 Huizinga, H. (2002), “Financial Services – VAT in Europe?” Economic Policy, October, 499-534 IBFD (2006), VAT Survey – Financial Services, Survey on the recovery of input VAT in the financial sector carried out for the European Commission, December 2006 Jack, W. (2000), “The Treatment of Financial Services Under a Broad-Based Consumption Tax” National Tax Journal 53, 841-851 Jenkins, G.P. and R. Khadka (1998), “Value-Added Tax Policy and Implementation in Singapore” International VAT Monitor 9(2), 35-47 Kogels, H.A. (2003), “Consumption Taxes and Financial Services – General Report” Cahiers de Droit Fiscal International 88b, 21-41 Lejeune, I., D. Stevens and M. Killer (2009), “The International Direction in the VAT Treatment of Financial Services” in M. Lang et al (eds.), Value Added Tax and Direct Taxation – Similarities and Differences (Amsterdam: IBFD, 2009), 673-701 Pallot, M. (2007), “GST and Financial Services – Rating Zero-rating” in R. Krever and D. White (eds.), GST in Retrospect and Prospect (Wellington: Thomson Brookers), 163- 178 Poddar, S.N. and M. English (1997), “Taxation of Financial Services Under a Value- Added Tax: Applying the Cash-Flow Approach” National Tax Journal 50, 89-111 OECD (2008), Consumption Tax Trends (Paris: OECD) OECD (1998), Indirect Tax Treatment of Financial Services and Instruments Pons, T. (2006), “Option for Taxation of Financial Services in France” International VAT Monitor 3, 182-185 PriceWaterhouse Coopers (2006), Study to Increase the Understanding of the Economic Effects of the VAT Exemption for Financial and Insurance Services - Final Report to the European Commission, 2 November 2006 Schenk, A. (2008), “Financial Services” in R. Krever (ed.), VAT in Africa (Pretoria: Pretoria University Press), 31-46 Swinkels, J. (2005), “Combating VAT avoidance” International VAT Monitor 4, 235-246 Swinkels, J. (2008), “The EU VAT Exemption for Cost-Sharing Associations” International VAT Monitor 1, 13-2 Thuronyi, V. (2003), Comparative Tax Law (Austin / Boston / Chicago / New York / The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International) Zee, H.H. (2005), “A New Approach to Taxing Financial Intermediation Services Under a Value-Added Tax” National Tax Journal 53(1), 77-92|
Actions (login required)