The Library

What is a critical journal?

Tools

Parker, Martin and Thomas, Robyn. (2011) What is a critical journal? Organization, Vol.18 (No.4). pp. 419-427. ISSN 1350-5084

Preview

PDF
WRAP_Parker_What_is_a_Critical_Journal_v4.pdf - Accepted Version - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
Download (230Kb)

Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1350508411403535

Abstract

Most competent editors should be able to make a clear statement about the scope, purposes and
values of their journal.
The boundary that they then draw provides a ground for justifications of
acceptance and rejection, as well as a description of some sort of community, or a group that
broadly recognizes itself as such. Sometimes, the community might be primarily articulated as
oppositional, in the sense that it relies on not being something else. Organization, as a ‘critical’
journal with a strong statement about its distinctiveness, often seems to fall into this category.
Implicitly or explicitly, ‘they’ are conservative whilst ‘we’ are radical. One term is defined by its
other, and so a description of the conservatives is the antonym of the radicals. There is something
comforting, even pious, about such a logic, suggesting, perhaps, that ‘they’ are stupid, narrow
minded or deluded whilst ‘we’ are clear sighted and pure of heart. The logic is reversible of course,
since the other side usually claims those virtues too. Such is the way that community and identity
are often built, but it’s an unstable set-up.

Item Type:

Journal Article

Subjects:

H Social Sciences > HF Commerce
P Language and Literature > PN Literature (General)

Divisions:

Faculty of Social Sciences > Warwick Business School

Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):

Organization, Business -- Periodicals, Periodicals -- History and criticism

Journal or Publication Title:

Organization

Publisher:

Sage Publications Ltd.

ISSN:

1350-5084

Official Date:

2011

Dates:

Date	Event
2011	Published

Volume:

Vol.18

Number:

No.4

Page Range:

pp. 419-427

Identification Number:

10.1177/1350508411403535

Status:

Peer Reviewed

Publication Status:

Published

Access rights to Published version:

Restricted or Subscription Access

References:

Alvesson, M, Bridgman, T and Willmott, H (eds) (2009) The Oxford Handbook of Critical Management Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Becher, T and Trowler, P (2001) Academic Tribes and Territories (2nd edition). Buckingham: SRHE/Open University Press.
Bourdieu. P (1990) Homo Academicus. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.
Bullock, A and Stallybrass, O (1977) The Fontana Dictionary of Modern Thought. London: Fontana.
Burrell, G, Calás, M, Reed, M, Smircich, L and Whitaker, A (1994) ‘Why Organization? Why now?’ Organization 1/1: 3-9.
Cooke, B, Perrow, C, Stookey, S, Adler, P, Willmott, H, Cunliffe, A and Voronov, M (2008) ‘Speaking Out on the Future of Critical Management Studies’ Organization 15/6: 912-945.
Douglas, M (1987) How Institutions Think. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Dunne, S, Harney, S and Parker, M (2008) ‘The Responsibilities of Management Intellectuals: A Survey’ Organization 15/2: 271-282.
Editors (2003) ‘Why Neo-Disciplinary? Why Now?’ Organization 10/3: 403-420.
Grey, C (2010) ‘Organizing Studies’ Organization Studies 31/6: 677-694.
Grey, C and Willmott, H (2002) ‘Contexts of CMS’ Organization 9/3: 411-418.
Jones, O, Sharifi, S and Conway, S (2006) ‘Accounting for Organization: Round up the Usual Suspects’ Accounting, Organizations and Society 17/2-3: 283-304.
Meriläinen, S, Tienari, J, Thomas, R and Davies, A (2008) ‘Hegemonic Academic Practices: Experiences of Publishing from the Periphery’ Organization 15/4: 584-597.
Parker, M (2010) ‘The Sclerosis of Criticism: A Handbook of Critical Management Studies?’ Critical Policy Studies 4/3: 297-302.
Thompson, P (2004) ‘A critical reflection on Critical Management Studies’. In Fleetwood, S and Ackroyd, S (eds) Critical Realist applications in Organization and Management Studies. London: Routledge, 54-70.
Troeltsch, E (1912/1956) The Social Teachings of the Christian Churches. London: Allen and Unwin.
Walsh, J and Weber, K (2002) ‘The Prospects for Critical Management Studies in the American Academy of Management’ Organization 9/3: 402-410