Is charity a homogeneous good?
Backus, Peter (2010) Is charity a homogeneous good? Working Paper. University of Warwick. Dept. of Economics, Coventry.
WRAP_Backus_twerp_951.pdf - Other - Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
Official URL: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/resear...
In this paper I estimate income and price elasticities of donations to six different charitable causes to test the assumption that charity is a homogeneous good. In the US, charitable donations can be deducted from taxable income. This has long been recognized as producing a price, or taxprice, of giving equal to one minus the marginal tax rate faced by the donor. A substantial portion of the economic literature on giving has focused on estimating price and income elasticities of giving as the received wisdom suggests that a price elasticity greater than unity is indicative of the ‘treasury efﬁciency’ of the tax deductibility of charitable contributions, as the loss to tax revenue is less than the increase in giving. However, a major limitation of nearly all the previous attempts to identify such effects has been the implicit assumption that charity is a homogeneous good, meaning giving to one type of charity is a perfect substitute for any other and that the causespeciﬁc responsiveness of giving to changes in price and income is equal across those causes. If this assumption is violated, then estimates may be biased and policies designed to increase charitable contributions may be sub-optimal. Results suggest that the tax-price of giving only affects giving to religious organisations and that the income effect is invariant over charitable causes.
|Item Type:||Working or Discussion Paper (Working Paper)|
|Subjects:||H Social Sciences > HB Economic Theory|
|Divisions:||Faculty of Social Sciences > Economics|
|Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):||Charity -- Economic aspects, Charity -- United States|
|Series Name:||Warwick economics research paper series (TWERPS)|
|Publisher:||University of Warwick. Dept. of Economics|
|Place of Publication:||Coventry|
|Status:||Not Peer Reviewed|
|Access rights to Published version:||Open Access|
|References:||ABRAMS, B. A., AND M. D. SCHITZ (1978): “The "crowding-out" effect of governmental transfers on private charitable contributions,” Public Choice, 33(1), 29–39. ACKERMAN, D., AND G. AUTEN (2008): “Tax Expenditures for Noncash Charitable Contributions,” NBER Chapters. National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc. AMEMIYA, T. (1974): “Multivariate Regression and Simultaneous Equation Models when the Dependent Variables Are Truncated Normal,” Econometrica, 42(6), 999–1012. ANDREONI, J. (1989): “Giving with Impure Altruism: Applications to Charity and Ricardian Equivalence,” Journal of Political Economy, 97(6), 1447–58. (1990): “Impure Altruism and Donations to Public Goods: A Theory of Warm-Glow Giving?,” Economic Journal, 100(401), 464–77. ANDREONI, J., E. BROWN, AND I. RISCHALL (2003): “Charitable giving by married couples: who decides and why does it matter?,” Journal of Human Resources, 38(1), 111. ANDREONI, J., J. K. SCHOLZ, AND W. G. GALE (1996): “Charitable Contributions of Time and Money,” Discussion paper, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Department of Economics. ATKINSON, A. (2009): “Giving overseas and public policy,” Journal of Public Economics, 93(5-6), 647–653. AUTEN, G. E., AND G. G. RUDNEY (1986): “Tax reform and individual giving to higher education,” Economics of Education Review, 5(2), 167–178. AUTEN, G. E., H. SIEG, AND C. T. CLOTFELTER (2002): “Charitable Giving, Income, and Taxes: An Analysis of Panel Data,” The American Economic Review, 92(1), 371–382. BAKIJA, J., AND B. HEIM (2008): “How Does Charitable Giving Respond to Incentives and Income? Dynamic Panel Estimates Accounting for Predictable Changes in Taxation,” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series, No. 14237, published as Jon Bakija & Bradley Heim, 2008. "How Does Charitable Giving Respond to Incentives and Income? Dynamic Panel Estimates Accounting for Predictable Changes in Taxation," NBER Chapters, in: Incentive and Distributional Consequences of Tax Expenditures National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc. BANKS, J., AND S. TANNER (1997): “The state of donation: household gifts to charity, 1974-96,” Discussion paper, Institute for Fiscal Studies. BARSLUND, M. (2007): “Estimation of Tobit Type Censored Demand Systems: A Comparison of Estimators,” University of Copenhagen. Department of Economics. BECKER, G. (1961): “Notes on an Economic Analysis of Philanthropy,” Working Paper, National Bureau of Economic Research. BECKER, G. S. (1974): “A theory of social interactions,” Journal of Political Economy, 82(6). BERGSTROM, T., L. BLUME, AND H. VARIAN (1986): “On the private provision of public goods,” Journal of Public Economics, 29(1), 25–49. BOSKIN, M. J., AND M. S. FELDSTEIN (1977): “Effects of the Charitable Deduction on Contributions by Low Income and Middle Income Households: Evidence from the National Survey of Philanthropy,” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 59(3), 351–54. BRADLEY, R., S. HOLDEN, AND R. MCCLELLAND (2005): “A robust estimation of the effects of taxation on charitable contributions,” Contemporary Economic Policy, 23(4), 545–554. BREUSCH, T. S., AND A. R. PAGAN (1980): “The Lagrange Multiplier Test and its Applications to Model Specification in Econometrics,” The Review of Economic Studies, 47(1), 239–253, ArticleType: research-article / Issue Title: Econometrics Issue / Full publication date: Jan., 1980 / Copyright Âct 1980 The Review of Economic Studies Ltd. BROMAN, A. (1989): “Statutory Tax Rate Reform and Charitable Contributions: Evidence from a Recent Period of Reform,” Journal of the American Taxation, 10(3), 7–20. BROWN, E. (1987): “Tax incentives and charitable giving: evidence from new survey data,” Public Finance Quarterly, 15(4), 386–96. BROWN, E., AND H. LANKFORD (1992): “Gifts of money and gifts of time estimating the effects of tax prices and available time,” Journal of Public Economics, 47(3), 321–341. CAPPELLARI, L., P. GHINETTI, AND G. TURATI (2007): “On Time and Money Donations,” CESifo Working Paper Series. CARMAN, K. G. (2003): “Social influences and the private provision of public goods: Evidence from charitable contributions in the workplace,” Manuscript, Stanford University. CHAMBERLAIN, G. (1982): “Multivariate regression models for panel data,” Journal of Econometrics, 18(1), 5–46. (1984): “Panel Data,” in Handbook of Econometrics Grilches, Z. and M. Intriligator, vol. 2. Amsterdam, North Holland. CHAVAS, J., AND K. KIM (2004): “A Heteroskedastic Multivariate Tobit Analysis of Price Dynamics in the Presence of Price Floors,” American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 86(3), 576–593. CLOTFELTER, C. T. (1980): “Tax incentives and charitable giving-Evidence from a panel of taxpayers,” Journal of Public Economics, 13(3), 319–340. (1997): “The economics of giving,” Giving Better, Giving Smarter. Washington, DC: National Commission on Philanthropy and Civic Renewal, pp. 31–55. CORNICK, J., T. L. COX, AND B. W. GOULD (1994): “Fluid Milk Purchases: A Multivariate Tobit Analysis,” American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 76(1), 74–82. DANIEL, J. (1989): “Price and Income Elasticities of Charitable Giving: New Evidence from a Panel of Taxpayers,” . DUNCAN, B. (1999): “Modeling charitable contributions of time and money,” Journal of Public Economics, 72(2), 213–242. DUNCAN, B. (2004): “A theory of impact philanthropy,” Journal of Public Economics, 88(9-10), 2159–2180. DYE, R. (1976): “Personal charitable contributions: tax effects and other motives,” Ph.D. thesis, University of Michigan. EATON, D. H. (2001): “Charitable contributions and tax price elasticities for nonitemizing taxpayers,” International Advances in Economic Research, 7(4), 431–442. ECKEL, C. C., AND P. J. GROSSMAN (2003): “Rebate versus matching: does how we subsidize charitable contributions matter?,” Journal of Public Economics, 87(3-4), 681–701. FACK, G., AND C. LANDAIS (2010): “Are Tax Incentives for Charitable Giving Efficient? Evidence from France,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2(2), 117–141. FEENBERG, D., AND E. COUTTS (1993): “An Introduction to the TAXSIM Model,” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 12(1), 189. FEIGENBAUM, S. (1980): “The case of income redistribution: a theory of government and private provision of collective goods,” Public Finance Review, 8(1), 3. FELDSTEIN, M. (1975a): “The Income Tax and Charitable Contributions: Part I-Aggregate and Distributional Effects,” National Tax Journal, pp. 81–100. (1975b): “The Income Tax and Charitable Contributions Part II-The Impact on Religious, Educational and Other Organizations,” National Tax Journal, 28(2). FELDSTEIN, M., AND C. CLOTFELTER (1976): “Tax incentives and charitable contributions in the United States: a microeconometric analysis,” Journal of Public Economics, 5(1-2), 1–26. FELDSTEIN, M., AND A. TAYLOR (1976): “The income tax and charitable contributions,” Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, 44(6), 1201–1222. GLENDAY, G., A. GUPTA, AND H. PAWLAK (1986): “Tax incentives for personal charitable contributions,” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 68(4), 688–693. GREENE, W. H. (2002): Econometric Analysis. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, 5th edn. GRUBER, J. (2004): “Pay or pray?: The impact of charitable subsidies on religious attendance,” Journal of Public Economics, 88(12), 2635–2655. HONORE, B. E. (1992): “Trimmed LAD and Least Squares Estimation of Truncated and Censored Regression Models with Fixed Effects,” Econometrica, 60(3), 533–65. (1998): “IV Estimation of Panel Data Tobit Models with Normal Errors,” . (2008): “On Marginal Effects in Semiparametric Censored Regression Models,” . HURD, M. (1979): “Estimation in truncated samples when there is heteroscedasticity,” Journal of Econometrics, 11(2-3), 247–258. KHANNA, J., J. POSNETT, AND T. SANDLER (1995): “Charity donations in the UK: New evidence based on panel data,” Journal of Public Economics, 56(2), 257–272. KHANNA, J., AND T. SANDLER (2000): “Partners in giving:: The crowding-in effects of UK government grants,” European Economic Review, 44(8), 1543–1556. KINGMA, B. (1989): “An accurate measurement of the crowd-out effect, income effect, and price effect for charitable contributions,” The journal of political economy, 97(5), 1197–1207. LANKFORD, R. H., AND J. H. WYCKOFF (1991): “Modeling Charitable Giving Using a Box-Cox Standard Tobit Model,” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 73(3), 460–70. LESLIE, L., AND G. RAMEY (1988): “Donor behavior and voluntary support for higher education institutions,” The Journal of Higher Education, 59(2), 115–132. MCCLELLAND, R., AND M. F. KOKOSKI (1994): “Econometric Issues in the Analysis of Charitable Giving,” Public Finance Review, 22(4), 498 –517. MEYERHOEFER, C. D., C. K. RANNEY, AND D. E. SAHN (2005): “Consistent Estimation of Censored Demand Systems Using Panel Data,” American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 87(3), 660–672. MICKLEWRIGHT, J., AND S. V. SCHNEPF (2009): “Who Gives Charitable Donations for Overseas Development?,” Journal of Social Policy, 38(02), 317–341. MUNDLAK, Y. (1978): “On the Pooling of Time Series and Cross Section Data,” Econometrica, 46(1), 69–85. OKTEN, C., AND U. OSILI (2005): “Ethnic Diversity and Charitable Giving,” Working Paper, IUPUI. O’NEIL, C., AND S. RICHARD (1996): “Reassesing the tax-favored status of the charitable deduction for gifts of appreciated assets,” National Tax Journal, 49(2), 215 233. POWELL, J. L. (1984): “Least absolute deviations estimation for the censored regression model,” Journal of Econometrics, 25(3), 303–325. RANDOLPH, W. (1995): “Dynamic income, progressive taxes, and the timing of charitable contributions,” Journal of Political Economy, 103(4), 709–738. REECE, W. (1979): “Charitable contributions: New evidence on household behavior,” The American Economic Review, 69(1), 142–151. REECE, W., AND K. ZIESCHANG (1985): “Consistent estimation of the impact of tax deductibility on the level of charitable contributions,” Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, 53(2), 271–293. REINSTEIN, D. A. (2006): “Does One Contribution Come at the Expense of Another? Empirical Evidence on Substitution Between Charitable Donations,” Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley. RIBAR, D., AND M. WILHELM (1995): “Charitable Contributions to International Relief and Development,” National Tax Journal, 48(2). ROBINSON, P. M. (1982): “On the Asymptotic Properties of Estimators of Models Containing Limited Dependent Variables,” Econometrica, 50(1), 27–41. SCHIFF, J. (1985): “Does government spending crowd out charitable contributions,” National Tax Journal, 38(4), 535–546. SCHWARTZ, R. (1970): “Personal philanthropic contributions,” The Journal of Political Economy, 78(6), 1264–1291. SHAIKH, S. L., AND D. M. LARSON (2003): “A Two-Constraint Almost Ideal Demand Model of Recreation and Donations,” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 85(4), 953–961. SLEMROD, J. (1989): “Are estimated tax elasticities really just tax evasion elasticities? The case of charitable contributions,” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 71(3), 517–522. TAUSSIG, M. (1967): “Economic aspects of the personal income tax treatment of charitable contributions,” National Tax Journal, 20(1), 1–19. TOBIN, J. (1958): “Estimation of Relationships for Limited Dependent Variables,” Econometrica, 26(1), 24–36. WALES, T. J., AND A. D. WOODLAND (1983): “Estimation of consumer demand systems with binding non-negativity constraints,” Journal of Econometrics, 21(3), 263–285. WILHELM, M. (2008): “Practical Considerations for Choosing Between Tobit and SCLS or CLAD Estimators for Censored Regression Models with an Application to Charitable Giving,” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 70(4), 559–582. WILHELM, M. O. (2006): “New data on charitable giving in the PSID,” Economics Letters, 92(1), 26–31. WOOLDRIDGE, J. M. (2002): Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. The MIT press. YEN, S., AND H. H. JENSEN (1996): “Determinants of Household Expenditures on Alcohol,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 30(1), 48–67. YEN, S. T. (2002): “An Econometric Analysis of Household Donations in the USA,” Applied Economics Letters, 9(13), 837–41. YEN, S. T., B. LIN, AND D. M. SMALLWOOD (2003): “Quasi- and Simulated-Likelihood Approaches to Censored Demand Systems: Food Consumption by Food Stamp Recipients in the United States,” American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 85(2), 458–478.|
Actions (login required)