Huang, Shu-er (2011) Ideal and reality of textbook selection : an interview- and questionnaire- based investigation in the Taiwanese tertiary context. Other thesis, University of Warwick.

Preview

PDF WRAP_THESIS_Huang_2011.pdf - Submitted Version - Requires a PDF viewer. Download (4Mb)

Request Changes to record.

Abstract

This mixed-methods study looks at the theory and practice of textbook selection,
describing the criteria that teachers say they actually use when selecting textbooks in the
Taiwanese tertiary context, exploring the reasons associated with these criteria, asking
teachers to prioritize overall among these criteria, and finally comparing these with the
suggestions for teachers which are put forward in the literature.
To my knowledge, no studies have either systematically investigated teachers‟ actual
criteria or, indeed, the reasons for these criteria and priorities among them. It is
therefore not clear whether the criteria recommended in the literature are appropriate for
helping teachers select a textbook for their own learners – indeed, the needs, objectives,
backgrounds and preferred styles of learners will differ from context to context, and it is
therefore likely that the criteria that have been suggested cannot necessarily be applied
to different teaching contexts.
This study employed an exploratory mixed-methods design, which first attempted to
explore Taiwanese teachers‟ criteria and reasons for selecting a textbook through
three-phase interviews, and second, based on the three-phase interview data, sought to
assess what degree of importance teachers attach to the different evaluation criteria
through an online questionnaire. The interviews were conducted with twenty-five
teachers in six selected Taiwanese tertiary contexts in Phase One and nineteen from the
same group in Phase Two. Also 138 questionnaires were completed and returned by a
large group of teachers (15.5 per cent return rate).
The main findings of this study are, first, that the use and role of the textbook described
by teachers in this context match quite well with what has been previously identified in
the literature. Second, the interview results show that the degree of teachers‟
involvement in evaluating and selecting textbooks varies. Their degree of involvement
and procedures for selection vary from university to university and from individual to
individual. Teachers do conduct pre-, in-, and post-use evaluation individually.
However, they do not conduct in-use and post-use evaluation systematically and/or in a
formal way. In some universities, post-use and pre-use evaluation as well as in-use and
post-use evaluation even overlap. Third, I systematically investigated teachers' actual
stated criteria in this context and explored reasons for their criteria in an in-depth manner. 70 criteria were identified as particularly important after being prioritised by
teachers in the survey. The criteria in the categories of Authenticity, Self-instruction,
and Cultural Issues attract considerable attention from teachers when they evaluate
materials. The most important individual criteria were also identified. Finally, it was
revealed that many teachers in this context have little or no training in evaluating
materials.
The significance of the study is, first, that this is the first study to systematically
investigate teachers‟ own criteria for textbook selection with their associated reasons
and priorities. Second, by reviewing the literature, I have provided a comparative
analysis and, on this basis, an original synthesis of published materials evaluation
criteria. This functioned to help me investigate the possible gaps between what teachers
actually consider when evaluating materials and what it is suggested teachers should
consider. The main gaps are in the category of Practical Concerns, which indicates that
the set of criteria teachers employ for selecting a textbook must come from within the
teaching context itself. Finally, the sequential exploratory mixed-methods design
employed for this study provided a more comprehensive view than would any one
method alone. This not only improved the quality of the final results in the present study,
but can also serve as a model for future researchers to explore the issues of materials
evaluation in their own, unique teaching contexts.

Item Type:	Thesis or Dissertation (Other)
Subjects:	L Education > LB Theory and practice of education > LB2300 Higher Education
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH):	College textbooks -- Taiwan
Official Date:	March 2011
Dates:	Date Event March 2011 Submitted
Institution:	University of Warwick
Theses Department:	Centre for Applied Linguistics
Thesis Type:	Other
Publication Status:	Unpublished
Supervisor(s)/Advisor:	Smith, Richard C., 1961- ; Pinter, Annamaria
Extent:	xi, 306 leaves : ill.
Language:	eng

Request changes or add full text files to a record

Repository staff actions (login required)

View Item

Downloads