The Library
Insanity and the capacity for criminal responsibility
Tools
Tadros, Victor (2001) Insanity and the capacity for criminal responsibility. Edinburgh Law Review, 5 (3). pp. 325-354. doi:10.3366/elr.2001.5.3.325 ISSN 1364-9809.
Research output not available from this repository.
Request-a-Copy directly from author or use local Library Get it For Me service.
Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.3366/elr.2001.5.3.325
Abstract
There are two different ways in which the insanity defence could he constructed. These relate to different ways in which the insanity defence might question the responsibility of the accused. Either the defence might show that the act in question was not performed in the appropriate way (that the accused lacks attribution-responsibility) or it might show that the agent was not an appropriate subject for criminal responsibility (that he or she lacks capacity-responsibility). Sometimes it is thought that these possibilities collapse into each other: it is only those that cannot perform their acts in the appropriate way that lack the capacity to be criminally responsible. This essay shows three things: first, that Scots criminal law, at least since the nineteenth century, is in a state of confusion between a capacity-responsibility conception of the defence and an attribution-responsibility conception. Second, that capacity-responsibility does not collapse into attribution-responsibility: there are some agents who are capable of forming mens rea but who ought not to be made criminally responsible due to their mental disorder. Third, that a sophisticated account of the capacity-responsibility conception can provide a version of the insanity defence that is both theoretically more elegant and practically more advantageous than the attribution-responsibility conception that has found favour in England and in some Scots decisions.
Item Type: | Journal Article | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Divisions: | Faculty of Social Sciences > School of Law | ||||
Journal or Publication Title: | Edinburgh Law Review | ||||
Publisher: | 1364-9809 | ||||
ISSN: | 1364-9809 | ||||
Official Date: | 2001 | ||||
Dates: |
|
||||
Volume: | 5 | ||||
Number: | 3 | ||||
Page Range: | pp. 325-354 | ||||
DOI: | 10.3366/elr.2001.5.3.325 | ||||
Status: | Peer Reviewed | ||||
Publication Status: | Published | ||||
Access rights to Published version: | Restricted or Subscription Access |
Request changes or add full text files to a record
Repository staff actions (login required)
View Item |